Treatment effects in sample selection models and their nonparametric estimation

In a sample-selection model with the ‘selection’ variable Q$Q$ and the ‘outcome’ variable Y^∗$Y^{\ast }$, Y^∗$Y^{\ast }$ is observed only when Q=1$Q=1$. For a treatment D$D$ affecting both Q$Q$ and Y^∗$Y^{\ast }$, three effects are of interest: ‘participation  ’ (i.e., the selection) effect of D$D$ on Q$Q$, ‘visible performance  ’ (i.e., the observed outcome) effect of D$D$ on Y≡QY^∗$Y\equiv Q{Y}^{\ast }$, and ‘invisible performance  ’ (i.e., the latent outcome) effect of D$D$ on Y^∗$Y^{\ast }$. This paper shows the conditions under which the three effects are identified, respectively, by the three corresponding mean differences of Q$Q$, Y$Y$, and Y|Q=1$Y|Q=1$ (i.e., Y^∗|Q=1$Y^{\ast }|Q=1$) across the control (D=0$D=0$) and treatment (D=1$D=1$) groups. Our nonparametric estimators for those effects adopt a two-sample framework and have several advantages over the usual matching methods. First, there is no need to select the number of matched observations. Second, the asymptotic distribution is easily obtained. Third, over-sampling the control/treatment group is allowed. Fourth, there is a built-in mechanism that takes into account the ‘non-overlapping support problem’, which the usual matching deals with by choosing a ‘caliper’. Fifth, a sensitivity analysis to gauge the presence of unobserved confounders is available. A simulation study is conducted to compare the proposed methods with matching methods, and a real data illustration is provided.     

Quasi ML estimation of the panel AR(1) model with arbitrary initial conditions

In this paper we show that the Quasi ML estimation method yields consistent Random and Fixed Effects estimators for the autoregression parameter ρ$\rho$ in the panel AR(1) model with arbitrary initial conditions and possibly time-series heteroskedasticity even when the error components are drawn from heterogeneous distributions. We investigate both analytically and by means of Monte Carlo simulations the properties of the QML estimators for ρ$\rho$. The RE(Q)MLE for ρ$\rho$ is asymptotically at least as robust to individual heterogeneity and, when the data are i.i.d. and normal, at least as efficient as the FE(Q)MLE for ρ$\rho$. Furthermore, the QML estimators for ρ$\rho$ only suffer from a ‘weak moment conditions’ problem when ρ$\rho$ is close to one if the cross-sectional average of the variances of the errors is (almost) constant over time, e.g. under time-series homoskedasticity. However, in this case the QML estimators for ρ$\rho$ are still consistent when ρ$\rho$ is local to or equal to one although they converge to a non-normal possibly asymmetric distribution at a rate that is lower than N^1/2$N^{1/2}$ but at least N^1/4$N^{1/4}$. Finally, we study the finite sample properties of two types of estimators for the standard errors of the QML estimators for ρ$\rho$, and the bounds of QML based confidence intervals for ρ$\rho$.     

Estimating deterministic trends with an integrated or stationary noise component

We propose a test for the slope of a trend function when it is a priori unknown whether the series is trend-stationary or contains an autoregressive unit root. The procedure is based on a Feasible Quasi Generalized Least Squares method from an AR(1) specification with parameter α$\alpha$, the sum of the autoregressive coefficients. The estimate of α$\alpha$ is the OLS estimate obtained from an autoregression applied to detrended data and is truncated to take a value 1 whenever the estimate is in a T^−δ$T^{-\delta }$ neighborhood of 1. This makes the estimate “super-efficient” when α=1$\alpha =1$ and implies that inference on the slope parameter can be performed using the standard Normal distribution whether α=1$\alpha =1$ or |α|<1$\left|\alpha \right|<1$. Theoretical arguments and simulation evidence show that δ=1/2$\delta =1/2$ is the appropriate choice. Simulations show that our procedure has better size and power properties than the tests proposed by [Bunzel, H., Vogelsang, T.J., 2005. Powerful trend function tests that are robust to strong serial correlation with an application to the Prebish–Singer hypothesis. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 23, 381–394] and [Harvey, D.I., Leybourne, S.J., Taylor, A.M.R., 2007. A simple, robust and powerful test of the trend hypothesis. Journal of Econometrics 141, 1302–1330].     

Semiparametric binary regression models under shape constraints with an application to Indian schooling data

We consider estimation of the regression function in a semiparametric binary regression model defined through an appropriate link function (with emphasis on the logistic link) using likelihood-ratio based inversion. The dichotomous response variable Δ$\Delta$ is influenced by a set of covariates that can be partitioned as (X,Z)$(X,Z)$ where Z$Z$ (real valued) is the covariate of primary interest and X$X$ (vector valued) denotes a set of control variables. For any fixed X$X$, the conditional probability of the event of interest (Δ=1$\Delta =1$) is assumed to be a non-decreasing function of Z$Z$. The effect of the control variables is captured by a regression parameter β$\beta$. We show that the baseline conditional probability function (corresponding to X=0$X=0$) can be estimated by isotonic regression procedures and develop a likelihood ratio based method for constructing asymptotic confidence intervals for the conditional probability function (the regression function) that avoids the need to estimate nuisance parameters. Interestingly enough, the calibration of the likelihood ratio based confidence sets for the regression function no longer involves the usual χ²${\chi }^2$ quantiles, but those of the distribution of a new random variable that can be characterized as a functional of convex minorants of Brownian motion with quadratic drift. Confidence sets for the regression parameter β$\beta$ can however be constructed using asymptotically χ²${\chi }^2$ likelihood ratio statistics. The finite sample performance of the methods are assessed via a simulation study. The techniques of the paper are applied to data sets on primary school attendance among children belonging to different socio-economic groups in rural India.     

Panel unit root tests in the presence of a multifactor error structure

This paper extends the cross-sectionally augmented panel unit root test (CIPS$CIPS$) proposed by Pesaran (2007) to the case of a multifactor error structure, and proposes a new panel unit root test based on a simple average of cross-sectionally augmented Sargan–Bhargava statistics (CSB$CSB$). The basic idea is to exploit information regarding the m$m$ unobserved factors that are shared by k$k$ observed time series in addition to the series under consideration. Initially, we develop the tests assuming that m⁰$m^0$, the true number of factors, is known and show that the limit distribution of the tests does not depend on any nuisance parameters, so long as k≥m⁰−1$k\ge m^0-1$. Small sample properties of the tests are investigated by Monte Carlo experiments and are shown to be satisfactory. Particularly, the proposed CIPS$CIPS$ and CSB$CSB$ tests have the correct size for all   combinations of the cross section (N$N$) and time series (T$T$) dimensions considered. The power of both tests rises with N$N$ and T$T$, although the CSB$CSB$ test performs better than the CIPS$CIPS$ test for smaller sample sizes. The various testing procedures are illustrated with empirical applications to real interest rates and real equity prices across countries.     

Nonstationary discrete choice: A corrigendum and addendum

We correct the limit theory presented in an earlier paper by Hu and Phillips [2004a. Nonstationary discrete choice. Journal of Econometrics 120, 103–138] for nonstationary time series discrete choice models with multiple choices and thresholds. The new limit theory shows that, in contrast to the binary choice model with nonstationary regressors and a zero threshold where there are dual rates of convergence (n^1/4$n^{1/4}$ and n^3/4$n^{3/4}$), all parameters including the thresholds converge at the rate n^3/4$n^{3/4}$. The presence of nonzero thresholds therefore materially affects rates of convergence. Dual rates of convergence reappear when stationary variables are present in the system. Some simulation evidence is provided, showing how the magnitude of the thresholds affects finite sample performance. A new finding is that predicted probabilities and marginal effect estimates have finite sample distributions that manifest a pile-up, or increasing density, towards the limits of the domain of definition.     

On the distribution of estimated technical efficiency in stochastic frontier models

We consider a stochastic frontier model with error ε=v−u$\epsilon =v-u$, where v$v$ is normal and u$u$ is half normal. We derive the distribution of the usual estimate of u,E(u|ε)$u,E\left(u\right|\epsilon )$. We show that as the variance of v$v$ approaches zero, E(u|ε)−u$E\left(u\right|\epsilon )-u$ converges to zero, while as the variance of v$v$ approaches infinity, E(u|ε)$E\left(u\right|\epsilon )$ converges to E(u)$E\left(u\right)$. We graph the density of E(u|ε)$E\left(u\right|\epsilon )$ for intermediate cases. To show that E(u|ε)$E\left(u\right|\epsilon )$ is a shrinkage of u towards its mean, we derive and graph the distribution of E(u|ε)$E\left(u\right|\epsilon )$ conditional on u$u$. We also consider the distribution of estimated inefficiency in the fixed-effects panel data setting.     

A complete asymptotic series for the autocovariance function of a long memory process

An infinite-order asymptotic expansion is given for the autocovariance function of a general stationary long-memory process with memory parameter d∈(−1/2,1/2)$d\in (-1/2,1/2)$. The class of spectral densities considered includes as a special case the stationary and invertible ARFIMA(p,d,q$p,d,q$) model. The leading term of the expansion is of the order O(1/k^1−2d)$O(1/k^{1-2d})$, where k$k$ is the autocovariance order, consistent with the well known power law decay for such processes, and is shown to be accurate to an error of O(1/k^3−2d)$O(1/k^{3-2d})$. The derivation uses Erdélyi’s [Erdélyi, A., 1956. Asymptotic Expansions. Dover Publications, Inc, New York] expansion for Fourier-type integrals when there are critical points at the boundaries of the range of integration - here the frequencies {0,2π}$\{0,2\pi \}$. Numerical evaluations show that the expansion is accurate even for small k$k$ in cases where the autocovariance sequence decays monotonically, and in other cases for moderate to large k$k$. The approximations are easy to compute across a variety of parameter values and models.     

Beyond panel unit root tests: Using multiple testing to determine the nonstationarity properties of individual series in a panel

Most panel unit root tests are designed to test the joint null hypothesis of a unit root for each individual series in a panel. After a rejection, it will often be of interest to identify which series can be deemed to be stationary and which series can be deemed nonstationary. Researchers will sometimes carry out this classification on the basis of n$n$ individual (univariate) unit root tests based on some ad hoc significance level. In this paper, we suggest and demonstrate how to use the false discovery rate (FDR)$\left(FDR\right)$ in evaluating I(1)/I(0)$I\left(1\right)/I\left(0\right)$ classifications.     

On the properties of the coefficient of determination in regression models with infinite variance variables

We examine the asymptotic properties of the coefficient of determination, R²$R^2$, in models with α-stable$\alpha \text{-stable}$   random variables. If the regressor and error term share the same index of stability α<2$\alpha <2$, we show that the R²$R^2$  statistic does not converge to a constant but has a nondegenerate distribution on the entire [0,1]$[0,1]$ interval. We provide closed-form expressions for the cumulative distribution function and probability density function of this limit random variable, and we show that the density function is unbounded at 0 and 1. If the indices of stability of the regressor and error term are unequal, we show that the coefficient of determination converges in probability to either 0 or 1, depending on which variable has the smaller index of stability, irrespective of the value of the slope coefficient. In an empirical application, we revisit the Fama and MacBeth (1973) two-stage regression and demonstrate that in the infinite-variance case the R²$R^2$  statistic of the second-stage regression converges to 0 in probability even if the slope coefficient is nonzero. We deduce that a small value of the R²$R^2$  statistic should not, in itself, be used to reject the usefulness of a regression model.     

A bootstrap theory for weakly integrated processes

This paper develops a bootstrap theory for models including autoregressive time series with roots approaching to unity as the sample size increases. In particular, we consider the processes with roots converging to unity with rates slower than n^-1$n^{-1}$. We call such processes weakly   integrated processes. It is established that the bootstrap relying on the estimated autoregressive model is generally consistent for the weakly integrated processes. Both the sample and bootstrap statistics of the weakly integrated processes are shown to yield the same normal asymptotics. Moreover, for the asymptotically pivotal statistics of the weakly integrated processes, the bootstrap is expected to provide an asymptotic refinement and give better approximations for the finite sample distributions than the first order asymptotic theory. For the weakly integrated processes, the magnitudes of potential refinements by the bootstrap are shown to be proportional to the rate at which the root of the underlying process converges to unity. The order of boostrap refinement can be as large as o(n^-1/2+?)$o(n^{-1/2+?})$ for any ?>0$?>0$. Our theory helps to explain the actual improvements observed by many practitioners, which are made by the use of the bootstrap in analyzing the models with roots close to unity.     

Identification and nonparametric estimation of a transformed additively separable model

Let r(x,z)$r(x,z)$ be a function that, along with its derivatives, can be consistently estimated nonparametrically. This paper discusses the identification and consistent estimation of the unknown functions H$H$, M$M$, G$G$ and F$F$, where r(x,z)=H[M(x,z)]$r(x,z)=H\left[M(x,z)\right]$, M(x,z)=G(x)+F(z)$M(x,z)=G\left(x\right)+F\left(z\right)$, and H$H$ is strictly monotonic. An estimation algorithm is proposed for each of the model’s unknown components when r(x,z)$r(x,z)$ represents a conditional mean function. The resulting estimators use marginal integration to separate the components G$G$ and F$F$. Our estimators are shown to have a limiting Normal distribution with a faster rate of convergence than unrestricted nonparametric alternatives. Their small sample performance is studied in a Monte Carlo experiment. We apply our results to estimate generalized homothetic production functions for four industries in the Chinese economy.     

A simple,robust and powerful test of the trend hypothesis

In this paper we develop a simple test procedure for a linear trend which does not require knowledge of the form of serial correlation in the data, is robust to strong serial correlation, and has a standard normal limiting null distribution under either I(0)$I(0)$ or I(1)$I(1)$ shocks. In contrast to other available robust linear trend tests, our proposed test achieves the Gaussian asymptotic local power envelope in both the I(0)$I(0)$ and I(1)$I(1)$ cases. For near-I(1)$I(1)$ errors our proposed procedure is conservative and a modification for this situation is suggested. An estimator of the trend parameter, together with an associated confidence interval, which is asymptotically efficient, again regardless of whether the shocks are I(0)$I(0)$ or I(1)$I(1)$, is also provided.     

Dominating estimators for minimum-variance portfolios

In this paper, we derive two shrinkage estimators for minimum-variance portfolios that dominate the traditional estimator with respect to the out-of-sample variance of the portfolio return. The presented results hold for any number of assets d≥4$d\ge 4$ and number of observations n≥d+2$n\ge d+2$. The small-sample properties of the shrinkage estimators as well as their large-sample properties for fixed d$d$ but n→∞$n\to \infty$ and n,d→∞$n,d\to \infty$ but n/d→q≤∞$n/d\to q\le \infty$ are investigated. Furthermore, we present a small-sample test for the question of whether it is better to completely ignore time series information in favor of naive diversification.