Availability and settlement of individual stock futures and options expiration-day effects: evidence from high-frequency data

This study examines whether the expiration-day effects of stock options traded in Australian Stock Exchange on return, volatility, trading volume, and temporary price changes of individual stocks vary with the availability and the settlement method of individual stock futures contracts. Using transaction data of the stocks that have both options and futures contacts from 1993 to 1997, we find that options expiration has significant effects on return and volatility of the underlying stocks in absence of individual stock futures. After introduction of a cash-settled stock futures contract, the effects decrease notably. However, the switch of a futures contract from cash settlement to physical delivery promotes the expiration effects on return and volatility and boosts temporary price changes on expiration days. Finally, options expiration has little effect on trading volume. Trading activity tends to behave normally regardless whether stock futures contracts are available or not.     

Uncertain tax rules and futures hedging

This paper considers the optimal futures hedging decision under uncertain tax treatment. If the Corn Products (CP) rule applies, gains or losses from futures trading can offset business gains or losses. However, under the Arkansas Best (AB) doctrine, offsetting is not allowed. We show that the risk neutral firm will not trade futures contracts if the probability the CP rule prevails is small. When the probability is sufficiently large, the firm will assume an underhedge. A risk averse firm is likely to trade, even if the AB rule prevails. As long as the CP ruling is not a sure thing, the firm will engage in underhedge. The effects of average business profits, the volatility of business profits, and risk aversion on the optimal futures position are provided. Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Forecasting and trading on the VIX futures market: A neural network approach based on open to close returns and coincident indicators

Previous work has highlighted the difficulty of obtaining accurate and economically significant predictions of VIX futures prices. We show that both low prediction errors and a significant amount of profitability can be obtained by using a neural network model to predict VIX futures returns. In particular, we focus on open-to-close returns (OTCRs) and consider intraday trading strategies, taking into account non-lagged exogenous variables that closely reflect the information possessed by traders at the time when they decide to invest. The neural network model with only the most recent exogenous variables (namely, the return on the Indian BSESN index) is superior to an unconstrained specification with ten lagged and coincident regressors, which is actually a form of weak efficiency involving markets of different countries. Moreover, the neural network turns out to be more profitable than either a logistic specification or heterogeneous autoregressive models.     

沪深300股指期货在现货交易和非交易时段交易特征的比较研究

我国沪深300股指期货交易2010年4月16日正式推出,但沪深300股指期货市场与沪深300现货市场的交易时间存在显著的差异,即相对于股票现货市场,沪深300股指期货市场提前15分钟开盘,延迟15分钟收盘。运用日内分笔数据和分钟数据,对沪深300股指期货不同交易时段的交易特征进行比较。研究表明,不同交易时段知情交易者市场参与度存在明显差异,提前交易时段知情交易的概率最高,现货交易时段次之,延迟交易时段最低;沪深300股指期货在开盘时段的交易提供了较大的价格发现,特别是开盘的第一笔交易包含有大量的私有信息,价格贡献最大;提前交易时段私有信息的价格发现贡献度最高;尽管提前交易时段的交易提供了较大的价格发现,但定价效率较低。     

Position limit for the CSI 300 stock index futures market

The aim of this study was to find the optimal position limit for the Chinese stock index (CSI) 300 futures market. A low position limit helps to prevent price manipulations in the spot market, and thus keeps the magnitude of instantaneous price changes within the tolerance range of policymakers. However, setting a position limit that is too low may also have negative effects on market quality. We propose an artificial limit order market with heterogeneous interacting agents to examine the impact of different levels of position limits on market quality, measured as liquidity, return volatility, efficiency of information dissemination, and trading welfare. The simulation model is based on realistic trading mechanisms, investor structure, and order submission behavior observed in the CSI 300 futures market.Our results show that on the basis of the liquidity status in September 2010, raising the position limit from 100 to 300 could significantly improve market quality and at the same time keep the maximum absolute price change per 5 s below the 2% tolerance level. However, the improvement becomes only marginal if the position limit is further increased beyond 300. Therefore, we believe that raising the position limit to a moderate level can enhance the functionality of the CSI 300 futures market, which should benefit the development of the Chinese financial system.     

Variance dynamics: Joint evidence from options and high-frequency returns

This paper analyzes the S&P 500 index return variance dynamics and the variance risk premium by combining information in variance swap rates constructed from options and quadratic variation estimators constructed from tick data on S&P 500 index futures. Estimation shows that the index return variance jumps. The jump arrival rate is not constant over time, but is proportional to the variance rate level. The variance jumps are not rare events but arrive frequently. Estimation also identifies a strongly negative variance risk premium, the absolute magnitude of which is proportional to the variance rate level.     

Market reactions to trade friction between China and the United States: Evidence from the soybean futures market

In March 2018, the US used an immense trade deficit as an excuse to provoke trade friction with China. This study uses the EGARCH model and event study methods to study the impact of the major risk event of Sino-US trade friction on soybean futures markets in China and the United States. Results indicate that the Sino-US trade friction weakened the return spillover effect between the soybean futures markets in China and the US, and significantly increased market volatilities. As the scale of additional tariffs increased, the volatility of the Chinese soybean futures market declined; however, the volatility of the US soybean futures market did not weaken. In addition, expanding the sources of soybean imports helped ease the impact of tariffs on China’s soybean futures market, while the decline in US soybean exports to China intensified the volatility of the US soybean futures market. In addition, while the release of multiple tariff increases has had a short-term impact on the returns of soybean futures markets, the impact of trade friction has gradually decreased.     

The strength and source of asymmetric international diversification

We find that correlations between international markets continue to increase over time compared to previous research, with only Asian markets providing lower correlations relative to American and European markets. Consistent with previous studies, the benefits from international diversification are asymmetric, with reduced diversification benefits during bear markets. We extend previous results by examining the characteristics and causes of the returns affecting these asymmetric correlations, relating these results to the herding behavior of investors across markets rather than to fundamental economic reasons. Specifically, we determine that the increase in correlations among markets is most closely associated with the larger correlations from the largest positive return time intervals in bear markets rather than the negative returns. Use of stock index futures avoids issues inherent in the use of international cash indexes.     

Did the introduction of Bitcoin futures crash the Bitcoin market at the end of 2017?

At the end of 2017, the Bitcoin price dropped significantly by approximately 70% over the two months. Since the introduction of Bitcoin futures coincided with this market crash, it is said that the new financial instrument might have caused the market crash. The literature states that the futures enabled investors to easily take a short position and hypothesizes that the selling pressure from futures could have potentially crashed the Bitcoin market. To evaluate this assumption, we investigate the empirical relationship between futures trading and the Bitcoin price by using high-frequency data. We find that Bitcoin futures trading was not significantly related to the returns on Bitcoin futures and spot returns. Therefore, we conclude that Bitcoin futures did not lead to the crash of the Bitcoin market at the end of 2017.     

Individual investors surpass their reputation: Trading behaviour on the Polish futures market

This paper examines individual investors’ trading behaviour by testing the presence of Monday and January anomalies on the Polish futures market, where individuals are the predominant trader type. Both anomalies are well established in the literature, and they are at least partially attributed to individual investors’ trading activities. We conduct an intraday analysis of trading volume, open interest, returns, and return volatility on the futures market in Poland and find the contribution of individuals to market anomalies to be grossly overstated. Hence, individual investors’ trading on the Polish futures market surpasses the prediction by the majority of investigations for mature stock markets.     

What do movements in financial traders’ net long positions reveal about aggregate stock returns?

Previous financial economics studies have successfully identified the existence of informed trading in futures markets; however, there is no study on the specific type of strategy chosen by informed agents to maximize profits. To fill this gap in the literature, we investigate the importance of movements in futures traders’ net long positions in predicting aggregate equity market returns. This study finds that movements in the net long positions of bond, commodity, and stock futures traders are strong predictors of aggregate stock returns as they outperform a large number of popular return predictors both in and out of sample. In addition, a one-standard-deviation change in futures traders’ net long positions can lead to an increase (decrease) of up to 3.4% (4.12%) in annualized market excess equity returns. The study’s first-order autocorrelation results reveal an absence of persistence in the net long predictors. A vector autoregression decomposition shows that the economic source of financial traders’ net long position predictive power stems predominantly from the discount rate and cash flow channels. Overall, the study finds that financial traders are informed traders who are able to anticipate future aggregate cash flows and associated discount rate news.     

The cross section of Chinese commodity futures return

This paper investigates the cross-section of expected commodity futures returns in China using a large panel of 13 individual factors. We find that 6 out of 13 individual factors produce positive and significant returns. To aggregate the information among these factors, we apply not only the traditional Fama-MacBeth regression (FM), but also a set of alternative methods, including the forecast combination method (FC), principal component analysis (PCA), principle component regression (PCR) and partial least squares (PLS). It turns out that PLS outperform other methods in forecasting the cross-section of Chinese expected futures returns. The equally weighted combination of 5 methods produces an even higher annualized return and lower standard deviation compared to each single method. The investigation of factor importance reveals that the skewness (SKEW) factor is more important than other factors in predicting expected futures returns in Chinese markets.     

投资者结构对于期货市场流动性影响的仿真研究

流动性是体现金融市场的质量与效率的简洁有效的指标之一,文章拟用u-mart平台就投资者结构对期货市场流动性的影响进行仿真研究。指出噪音交易者对于提供市场流动性的作用。其在市场参与者中的比例与市场流动性的关系并不能完全确定,但大约占60%时效果最好。     

Reading Keynes' Treatise on Probability

A Treatise on Probability was published by John Maynard Keynes in 1921. The Treatise contains a critical assessment of the philosophical foundations of probability and of the statistical methodology at the time. We review the aspects of the book that are most related with statistics, avoiding uninteresting neophyte's forrays into philosophical issues. In particular, we examine the arguments provided by Keynes against the Bayesian approach, as well as the sketchy alternative of a return to Lexis' theory of analogies he proposes. Our conclusion is that the Treatise is a scholarly piece of work looking at past advances rather than producing directions for the future.     

An economic–probabilistic model for risk analysis in technological innovation projects

This paper presents the application of an economic–probabilistic model to conduct risk analysis in technological innovation (TI) projects. The model integrates risk and economic analysis by quantifying both value and probability of occurrence of cash flow deviations, thus resulting in an economic–probabilistic analysis of the expected returns. The main risk categories and factors in TI projects are identified and associated to cash flow groups. The model allows to calculate risk-adjusted values for cash flow groups and project net present value through stochastic simulation. As a result, the model provides both the risk-adjusted project economic return with the associated probability distribution to its NPV and the variability that each risk factor generates in the project return. The model offers important benefits from the point of view of practitioners, including a condensed list of independent risk factors and the use of a monetary scale to assess risk impact which is familiar to most decision makers.     

Futures options with futures-style margining in the Gaussian models setting

This paper investigates the effects of the markung-to-market on futures and futures options. Closed form solutions for the pricung of these contracts are derived under the assumption that the forward rate follows a Gaussian model. Moreover, an upper bound of the error made by computing futures option prices under the contmuons marking-to-market instead of the discrete one is provided. Numerical comparisons suggest that the marking-to-market feature is highly affect by the model chosen. In the Ho and Lee framework discrete marking-to-market futures prices turned out to be slightly different from the continuous ones; whereas in the Vasicek model differences in prices become appreciable when the mean reversion is slow and the volatility is high.

---

Valutazione di contratti futures e opzioni futures nell’ambito dei modelli Gaussiani

Riassunto In questo articolo si esaminano gli effetti di marking-to-market nella determinazione del prezzo di contratti futures e di opzioni futures. Le espressioni in forma chiusa dei prezzi di questi contratti sono determinate sotto l’ipotesi che l’intensità istantanea di interesse si evolva secondo nn modello Gaussiano. Tra i contratri futures e opzioni futures su tassi di interesse a breve trartati al LIFFE, dedichiamo la nostra analisi in particolare al caso di contratti su Eurolira. Questi contratti rappresentano infatti un fondamentale strumento per iltrading e l’hedging nel mercato Italiano dove i tassi di interesse a breve mostrano alti livelli di volatilità. Confronti unmerjci vengono foruiti nell’ambito del modello di Ho e Lee e di Vasicek. I risultati empirici suggeriscono che le differenze di prezzo nel caso discreto e continuo diventano apprezzabili nel modello di Vasicek quando laincan-veversion è bassa e la volatilità è alta.

     

A reduced form framework for modeling volatility of speculative prices based on realized variation measures

Building on realized variance and bipower variation measures constructed from high-frequency financial prices, we propose a simple reduced form framework for effectively incorporating intraday data into the modeling of daily return volatility. We decompose the total daily return variability into the continuous sample path variance, the variation arising from discontinuous jumps that occur during the trading day, as well as the overnight return variance. Our empirical results, based on long samples of high-frequency equity and bond futures returns, suggest that the dynamic dependencies in the daily continuous sample path variability are well described by an approximate long-memory HAR–GARCH model, while the overnight returns may be modeled by an augmented GARCH type structure. The dynamic dependencies in the non-parametrically identified significant jumps appear to be well described by the combination of an ACH model for the time-varying jump intensities coupled with a relatively simple log-linear structure for the jump sizes. Finally, we discuss how the resulting reduced form model structure for each of the three components may be used in the construction of out-of-sample forecasts for the total return volatility.     

Evidence of information transmission across currency futures markets using frequency domain tests

In this article, I examine the returns and volatility spillovers in the currency futures market incorporating the recently developed frequency domain tests. Such analysis allows differentiating between permanent (long-run) and transitory (short-run) linkages among the currency futures markets by investigating the causality dynamics at low and high frequencies respectively. I detect significant informational linkages between USD, EUR, GBP and JPY futures contracts in the Indian currency futures market. Evidence of innovations from USD futures market to other markets is the most significant for returns spillover and for volatility spillover, EUR is found to be the most significant compared to other currency futures contracts. The results would have implications for the market participants and policymakers.     

Spread volume for currency futures

We use a new futures database to identify and determine the importance of spread volume for currency futures and hence the liquidity available for spreading. Spreads are a significant proportion of total volume for currency futures, with both calendar and cross-spreads being significant. Commercial traders and the general public generate most of the spread volume, while floor traders do not generate much volume. The amount of spread trading has significant implications for volume-volatility studies, since spread volume is not considered to be “informed trading” and since it has a pronounced seasonal character.     

How to poison Poisson (when approximating binomial tails)*

Summary In these days some sportsmen are given dangerous drugs in order to stimulate them into still higher efforts. The present paper wants to add some poison to the classical approximation of a binomial by a Poisson distribution. The relatively harmless drug of a little extra calculation shall be seen to result in a much better accuracy. This paper reports both on theoretical considerations, following from series expansions of Poisson-type parameters, and on extensive numerical investigations of accuracy by means of an Electrologica X8 computer. The main conclusion is that the probability of at most k successes in n Bernoulli trials with success probability p <.5 can be very closely approximated by the probability of at most k events in a Poisson distribution with expectation not np but (12–2p)n-7kζ= (12–8p)n-k+k/n^np. In the case p > 5 one should make p < .5 by a reversal, i.e. the interchanging of successes and failures, before the application of a Poisson-type approximation (with one exception mentioned in section 4). For the probability of at least j successes one should approximate the complementary probability of at most j—1 successes. After an introductory section 1 and a discussion of measures of accuracy in section 2, the existing Poisson-type approximations are treated in section 3. The fourth section introduces a new parameter and discusses the advantages of reversal in other situations than p > 5. In section 5 a series expansion for the exact Poisson parameter is derived. Two new parameters, among which is ζ, are introduced in section 6, where the series expansions for parameters given in table 4 lead to conclusions about the various approximations, summarized in table 6. The final section 7 gives some numerical results, which confirm to a large extent the conclusions from the asymptotic expansions.