The use of mixed methods research in the field of behavioural sciences

Mixed methods research involves the combined use of quantitative and qualitative methods in the same research study, and it is becoming increasingly important in several scientific areas. The aim of this paper is to review and compare through a mixed methods multiple-case study the application of this methodology in three reputable behavioural science journals: the Journal of Organizational Behavior, Addictive Behaviors and Psicothema. A quantitative analysis was carried out to review all the papers published in these journals during the period 2003–2008 and classify them into two blocks: theoretical and empirical, with the latter being further subdivided into three subtypes (quantitative, qualitative and mixed). A qualitative analysis determined the main characteristics of the mixed methods studies identified, in order to describe in more detail the ways in which the two methods are combined based on their purpose, priority, implementation and research design. From the journals selected, a total of 1,958 articles were analysed, the majority of which corresponded to empirical studies, with only a small number referring to research that used mixed methods. Nonetheless, mixed methods research does appear in all the behavioural science journals studied within the period selected, showing a range of designs, where the sequential equal weight mixed methods research design seems to stand out.     

ECONOMETRICS MEETS SENTIMENT: AN OVERVIEW OF METHODOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS

The advent of massive amounts of textual, audio, and visual data has spurred the development of econometric methodology to transform qualitative sentiment data into quantitative sentiment variables, and to use those variables in an econometric analysis of the relationships between sentiment and other variables. We survey this emerging research field and refer to it as sentometrics, which is a portmanteau of sentiment and econometrics. We provide a synthesis of the relevant methodological approaches, illustrate with empirical results, and discuss useful software.     

A method to obtain new copulas from a given one

Given a strictly increasing continuous function φ from [0, 1] to [0, 1] and its pseudo-inverse φ^[−1], conditions that φ must satisfy for C_φ(x₁, . . . ,x_n)=φ^[−1](C(φ(x₁), . . . ,φ(x_n))) to be a copula for any copula C are studied. Some basic properties of the copulas obtained in this way are analyzed and several examples of generator functions φ that can be used to construct copulas C_φ are presented. In this manner, a method to obtain from a given copula C a variety of new copulas is provided. This method generalizes that used to construct Archimedean copulas in which the original copula C is the product copula, and it is related with mixtures     

Can Findings of Qualitative Research in Education be Generalized?

Most qualitative researchers do not recommend generalization from qualitative studies, as this research is not based on random samples and statistical controls. The objective of this study is to explore the degree to which in-service teachers understand the controversial aspects of generalization in both qualitative and quantitative educational research and as to how this can facilitate problems faced by the teachers in the classroom. The study is based on 83 participants who had registered for a 10-week course on ‘Methodology of Investigation in Education’ as part of their Master’s degree program. The course is based on 11 readings drawing on a philosophy of science perspective (positivism, constructivism, Popper, Kuhn, Lakatos). Course activities included written reports, class room discussions based on participants’ presentations, and written exams. Based on the results obtained it is concluded: (1) almost 91% of the teachers agreed that external generalization in a different social context is feasible; (2) almost 63% of the participants used a fairly inconsistent approach, that is in a theoretical context agreed that qualitative research cannot be generalized and still when asked with respect to the experience of two particular teachers, agreed that generalization was possible; (3) almost 28% of the participants used a consistent approach. Some of the reasons provided by the participants as to why generalization was feasible are discussed. An analogy is drawn with respect to Piaget’s methodology, viz., it was not based on random samples or statistical treatments and still his oeuvre has been generalized (criticisms not withstanding) in both the psychology and educational literature.     

A note on the maximum deviation of the scale-contaminated normal to the best normal distribution

In this paper we consider the case of the scale-contaminated normal (mixture of two normals with equal mean components but different component variances: (1−p)N(μ,σ²)+pN(μ,τ²) with σ and τ being non-negative and 0≤p≤1). Here is the scale error and p denotes the amount with which this error occurs. It's maximum deviation to the best normal distribution is studied and shown to be montone increasing with increasing scale error. A closed-form expression is derived for the proportion which maximizes the maximum deviation of the mixture of normals to the best normal distribution. Implications to power studies of tests for normality are pointed out. Received May 2001     

Estimating a restricted normal mean

Let X ₁, X ₂, ..., X _n be a random sample from a normal distribution with unknown mean μ and known variance σ ². In many practical situations, μ is known a priori to be restricted to a bounded interval, say [−m, m] for some m > 0. The sample mean , then, becomes an inadmissible estimator for μ. It is also not minimax with respect to the squared error loss function. Minimax and other estimators for this problem have been studied by Casella and Strawderman (Ann Stat 9:870–878, 1981), Bickel (Ann Stat 9:1301–1309, 1981) and Gatsonis et al. (Stat Prob Lett 6:21–30, 1987) etc. In this paper, we obtain some new estimators for μ. The case when the variance σ ² is unknown is also studied and various estimators for μ are proposed. Risk performance of all estimators is numerically compared for both the cases when σ ² may be known and unknown.     

D-optimal weighing designs for six objects

For all integers m≥6, we determine the maximum value of det X ^T X, where X is an m×6 (0, 1)-matrix, and exhibit (D-optimal) matrices X for which the maximum occurs. For D-optimal matrices X, the uniqueness of the Gram matrix X ^T X is discussed. Received: May 2000     

Generalization practices in qualitative research: a mixed methods case study

The purpose of this mixed methods case study was to examine the generalization practices in qualitative research published in a reputable qualitative journal. In order to accomplish this, all qualitative research articles published in Qualitative Report since its inception in 1990 (n =  273) were examined. A quantitative analysis of the all 125 empirical qualitative research articles revealed that a significant proportion (i.e., 29.6%) of studies involved generalizations beyond the underlying sample that were made inappropriately by the author(s). A qualitative analysis identified the types of over-generalizations that occurred, which included making general recommendations for future practice and providing general policy implications based only on a few cases. Thus, a significant proportion of articles published in Qualitative Report lack what we call interpretive consistency.     

sk−p Fractional factorial designs in sb blocks

Draper and Guttman (1997) shows that for basic 2^k−p designs, p≥0, k − p replicates of blocks designs of size two are needed to estimate all the usual (estimable) effects. In this work, we provide an algebraic formal proof for the two-level blocks designs results and present results applicable to the general case; that is, for the case of s ^k factorial (p=0) or s ^k−p fractional factorial (p >0) designs in s ^b blocks, where 0<b<k− p, at least replicates are needed to clear up all possible effects. Through the theoretical development presented in this work, it can provide a clearer view on why those results would hold. We will also discuss the estimation equations given in Draper and Guttman (1997).  Research supported in part by the National Science Council of Taiwan, R.O.C., Grant No. NSC 89-2118-M110-010. Acknowledgement. The authors would like to thank the referee for very helpful comments.     

Largest excess of boundary crossings for martingales

Summary LetX ₁,X ₂, ... form a sequence of martingale differences and denote byZ(a, α) = sup n (S _n −an ^α)⁺ the largest excess forS _n =X ₁ + ... +X _n crossing the boundaryan ^α. We give a sufficient condition for the finiteness ofEZ(a, α)^β which is formulated in terms of bounds forE(X _i ^{+ p} andE(|X _i |γ|X ₁, ...,X _i-1), whereα, β, γ, p are suitably related. This general result is then applied to the case of independent random variables.     

Testing whetherF is more IFR thanG

A distributionF is said to be “more IFR” than another distributionG ifG ⁻¹ F is convex. WhenF(0) =G(0) = 0, the problem of testingH ₀ :F(x) =G (θx) for someθ > 0 andx ⩾ 0, against the alternativeH _A:F is more IFR thanG, is considered in this paper. Both cases, whenG is completely specified (one-sample case) and when it is not specified but a random sample form it is available (two-sample case) are considered. The proposed tests are based onU-statistics. The asymptotic relative efficiency of the tests are compared with several other tests and the test statistics remain asymptotically normal under certain dependency assumptions. Research supported in part by a grant from the US Air Force Office of Scientific Research.     

Choice of optimal initial designs in sequential experiments

Combined-optimal designs (Li and Lin, 2003) are obviously the best choices for the initial designs if we partition the experiment into two parts with equal size to obtain some information about the process, especially for the case not considering the blocking factor. In this paper, the definition of combined-optimal design is extended to the case when blocking factor is significant, and this new class of designs is called blocked combined-optimal designs. Some general results are obtained which relate 2^k−p_III initial designs with their complementary designs when , where n=2^k−p. By applying these results, we are able to characterize 2^k−p_III combined-optimal designs or blocked combined-optimal designs in terms of their complementary designs. It is also proved that both 2^k−p_III combined-optimal and blocked combined-optimal designs are not minimum aberration designs when and n−1−k > 2. And some combined-optimal and blocked combined-optimal designs with 16 and 32 runs are constructed for illustration. 2000 Mathematics Subject Classifications: 62K15, 62K05     

A minimal characterization of the covariance matrix

Summary LetX be ak-dimensional random vector with mean vectorμ and non-singular covariance matrix Σ. We show that among all pairs (a, Δ),a ∈ IR ^k , Δ ∈ IR ^k×k positive definite and symmetric andE(X−a)′ Δ⁻¹(X−a)=k, (μ, Σ) is the unique pair which minimizes det Δ. This motivates certain robust estimators of location and scale. Research supported by the Nuffield Foundation.     

Estimates of technical inefficiency in stochastic frontier models with panel data: generalized panel jackknife estimation

Estimates of technical inefficiency based on fixed effects estimation of the stochastic frontier model with panel data are biased upward. Previous work has attempted to correct this bias using the bootstrap, but in simulations the bootstrap corrects only part of the bias. The usual panel jackknife is based on the assumption that the bias is of order T ⁻¹ and is similar to the bootstrap. We show that when there is a tie or a near tie for the best firm, the bias is of order T ^−1/2, not T ⁻¹, and this calls for a different form of the jackknife. The generalized panel jackknife is quite successful in removing the bias. However, the resulting estimates have a large variance.     

A characterization of the normal distribution by sufficiency of the least squares estimation

Summary For a linear modelY =ϑ + Z,ϑ ∈V,V ⊂ ℝ ⁿ a linear space, the following theorem is proved under simple conditions on the subspaceV: The projection onV (i.e. the least squares estimate forϑ) is a sufficient statistic iffZ is normally distributed. Further, this result is extended to the case of a multivariate linear model.     

Modern Likelihood‐Frequentist Inference

We offer an exposition of modern higher order likelihood inference and introduce software to implement this in a quite general setting. The aim is to make more accessible an important development in statistical theory and practice. The software, implemented in an R package, requires only that the user provide code to compute the likelihood function and to specify extra‐likelihood aspects of the model, such as stopping rule or censoring model, through a function generating a dataset under the model. The exposition charts a narrow course through the developments, intending thereby to make these more widely accessible. It includes the likelihood ratio approximation to the distribution of the maximum likelihood estimator, that is the p^? formula, and the transformation of this yielding a second‐order approximation to the distribution of the signed likelihood ratio test statistic, based on a modified signed likelihood ratio statistic r^?. This follows developments of Barndorff‐Nielsen and others. The software utilises the approximation to required Jacobians as developed by Skovgaard, which is included in the exposition. Several examples of using the software are provided.     

<Emphasis Type="SmallCaps">Notes and Comments:</Emphasis> On the uniqueness of convex-ranged probabilities

Abstract In Marinacci (2000), the following theorem was proved. Theorem 1. (Marinacci (2000) Let P and Q be two finitely additive probabilities on a λ -system Σ . Suppose that P is convex-ranged and that Q is countably additive. If there exists an A ⁺ ∈ Σ with 0<P(A ⁺ )<1 such that whenever B∈ Σ , then P=Q. Mathematics Subject Classification (2000): 28A10, 91B06 Journal of Economic Literature Classification: C60, D81     

Estimation of the location parameter under LINEX loss function: multivariate case

The Baysian estimation of the mean vector θ of a p-variate normal distribution under linear exponential (LINEX) loss function is studied when as a special restricted model, it is suspected that for a p × r known matrix Z the hypothesis θ = Zβ, ${\beta\in\Re^r}The Baysian estimation of the mean vector θ of a p-variate normal distribution under linear exponential (LINEX) loss function is studied when as a special restricted model, it is suspected that for a p × r known matrix Z the hypothesis θ = Zβ, b ? ?^r{\beta\in\Re^r} may hold. In this area we show that the Bayes and empirical Bayes estimators dominate the unrestricted estimator (when nothing is known about the mean vector θ).     

Generalized entropies in coding theory

Equivalence of the generalized entropyH ^β (P, Φ _t ) defined in this paper andKapur’s entropy of orderα and typeβ, ie.H _α ^β (P), is established. The results given recently byCampbell follow as special cases. International Conference on System Sciences, Honolulu, January 1968.     

Characterization of the multivariate normal distribution by conditional normal distributions

Summary LetX andY be two random vectors with values in ℝ ^k and ℝ∝, respectively. IfZ=(X ^T,Y ^T) ^T is multivariate normal thenX givenY=y andY givenX=x are (multivariate) normal; the converse is wrong. In this paper simple additional conditions are stated such that the converse is true, too. Furthermore, the case is treated that the random vectorZ=(X ₁ ^T , …,X _t ^T ) ^T is splitted intot≥3 partsX ₁, …,X _t.