Seasonal adjustment perspectives on “Damping seasonal factors: shrinkage estimators for the X-12-ARIMA program”

We examined the shrinkage methods of Miller and William from the perspective of seasonal adjustment rather than forecasting, restricting attention to their performance on the approximately 500 of the 1428 M3 series that are seasonal and have multiplicative seasonality. Local shrinkage improved the quality of the seasonal adjustment of enough of these series that almost 50% have acceptable automatic X-12-ARIMA adjustments, instead of 40% with no shrinkage. For a few series, global shrinkage produced demonstrably incorrect results, and for some of these series and also others improved by local shrinkage, the SEATS seasonal adjustment provided by an experimental version of X-12-ARIMA offered still greater improvements. No benefits were observed from global shrinkage.     

X-12-ARIMA中调整类似春节效应的模型研究及应用

由于X-12-ARIMA只根据美国的假日情况设定了复活节、劳动节和感恩节三种移动假日效应的调整,其调整方法不适用中国特有的类似春节效应的调整。因此,本文针对中国现有的类似春节效应调整模型中存在的局限性,构建了扩展的L-Z模型体系,并与X-12-ARIMA程序相结合,形成了一套具有中国特色的调整方案。同时利用新的调整方案对中国工业增加值中存在的类似春节效应进行了有效调整,得到的经季节调整数据可以更好地满足经济分析的要求。对X-12-ARIMA进行本地化改造后,不但应用效果更好,而且应用范围也更加广泛。     

如何对中国CPI进行季节调整——基于X-12-ARIMA方法的改进

本文基于X-12-ARIMA方法,针对中国CPI存在的类似春节等移动假日效应调整问题,得到改进的X-12-ARIMA-BHG和X-12-ARIMA-LZ方法,利用改进的方法进行季节调整可更加准确地反映中国CPI的基本发展趋势。同时利用改进的方法对2010年12月至2011年6月份的中国CPI进行预测,得到了具有指导意义的预测结果。     

The tourism forecasting competition

We evaluate the performances of various methods for forecasting tourism data. The data used include 366 monthly series, 427 quarterly series and 518 annual series, all supplied to us by either tourism bodies or academics who had used them in previous tourism forecasting studies. The forecasting methods implemented in the competition are univariate and multivariate time series approaches, and econometric models. This forecasting competition differs from previous competitions in several ways: (i) we concentrate on tourism data only; (ii) we include approaches with explanatory variables; (iii) we evaluate the forecast interval coverage as well as the point forecast accuracy; (iv) we observe the effect of temporal aggregation on the forecasting accuracy; and (v) we consider the mean absolute scaled error as an alternative forecasting accuracy measure. We find that pure time series approaches provide more accurate forecasts for tourism data than models with explanatory variables. For seasonal data we implement three fully automated pure time series algorithms that generate accurate point forecasts, and two of these also produce forecast coverage probabilities which are satisfactorily close to the nominal rates. For annual data we find that Naïve forecasts are hard to beat.     

Periodic Unobserved Cycles in Seasonal Time Series with an Application to US Unemployment*

We introduce a general class of periodic unobserved component (UC) time series models with stochastic trend and seasonal components and with a novel periodic stochastic cycle component. The general state space formulation of the periodic model allows for exact maximum likelihood estimation, signal extraction and forecasting. The consequences for model‐based seasonal adjustment are discussed. The new periodic model is applied to postwar monthly US unemployment series from which we identify a significant periodic stochastic cycle. A detailed periodic analysis is presented including a comparison between the performances of periodic and non‐periodic UC models.     

Advances in forecasting with neural networks? Empirical evidence from the NN3 competition on time series prediction

This paper reports the results of the NN3 competition, which is a replication of the M3 competition with an extension of the competition towards neural network (NN) and computational intelligence (CI) methods, in order to assess what progress has been made in the 10 years since the M3 competition. Two masked subsets of the M3 monthly industry data, containing 111 and 11 empirical time series respectively, were chosen, controlling for multiple data conditions of time series length (short/long), data patterns (seasonal/non-seasonal) and forecasting horizons (short/medium/long). The relative forecasting accuracy was assessed using the metrics from the M3, together with later extensions of scaled measures, and non-parametric statistical tests. The NN3 competition attracted 59 submissions from NN, CI and statistics, making it the largest CI competition on time series data. Its main findings include: (a) only one NN outperformed the damped trend using the sMAPE, but more contenders outperformed the AutomatANN of the M3; (b) ensembles of CI approaches performed very well, better than combinations of statistical methods; (c) a novel, complex statistical method outperformed all statistical and CI benchmarks; and (d) for the most difficult subset of short and seasonal series, a methodology employing echo state neural networks outperformed all others. The NN3 results highlight the ability of NN to handle complex data, including short and seasonal time series, beyond prior expectations, and thus identify multiple avenues for future research.     

Changes in regional input-output coefficients and regional forecasting

The issue of constant regional input-output coefficients is studied in the context of regional forecasting. Under the constant coefficient assumption and given known final demand vectors, output and intermediate output prediction errors average five and 20 percent, respectively. Neither price nor product-mix adjustments improve predictions, and measurement error in base-year tables accounts for only a portion of the observed variation in coefficients. On the other hand, the interindustry structure is sensitive to short-run disturbances in the region's propensity to import. Tests further indicate that input-output forecasting is superior to a series of naive methods, but that the problem of predicting regional final demands is a relatively serious one.     

Shrinkage estimators of time series seasonal factors and their effect on forecasting accuracy

This paper shows that forecasting accuracy can be improved through better estimation of seasonal factors under conditions for which relatively simple methods are preferred, such as relatively few historical data, noisy data, and/or a large number of series to be forecasted. In such situations, the preferred method of seasonal adjustment is often ratio-to-moving-averages (classical) decomposition. This paper proposes two shrinkage estimators to improve the accuracy of classical decomposition seasonal factors. In a simulation study, both of the proposed estimators provided consistently greater accuracy than classical decomposition, with the improvement sometimes being dramatic. The performances of the two estimators depended on characteristics of the series, and guidelines were developed for choosing one of them under a given set of conditions. For a set of monthly, M-competition series, greater forecasting accuracy was achieved when either of the proposed methods was used for seasonal adjustment rather than classical decomposition, and the greatest accuracy was achieved by following the guidelines for choosing a method.     

我国铁路客运量的组合预测

首先对我国月度铁路客运量的变动特征进行了分析,并结合多元线性回归和时间序列预测两种模型,运用组合预测方法对2009年1月至12月的铁路客运量进行了预测,结果表明预测误差小,组合预测精度相对单个预测方法均有所提高,说明组合预测是月度铁路客运量预测的有效方法。     

Time Series Analysis of Repeated Surveys: The State–space Approach

Cross sectional estimates from repeated surveys form a time series { y_t }. These estimates can be viewed as the sum y _t = Y _t + e _t of two processes, { Y _t }, the population process and { e _t }, the survey error process. Serial correlations in the latter series are usually present, mainly due to sample overlap. Other sources of data such as censuses, administrative records and demographic population counts are also available. The state–space modelling approach to the analysis of repeated surveys allows combining information from different sources, incorporating benchmarking constraints in a natural way. Results from these methods seem to compare favourably with those from X-11-ARIMA in filtering out survey errors.     

Comparison of seasonal estimation methods in multi-item short-term forecasting

This paper addresses the issue of estimating seasonal indices for multi-item, short-term forecasting, based upon both individual time series estimates and groups of similar time series. This development of the joint use of individual and group seasonal estimation is extended in two directions. One class of methods is derived from the procedures developed for combining forecasts. The second employs the general class of Stein Rules to obtain shrinkage estimates of seasonal components. A comparative evaluation has been undertaken of several versions of these methods, based upon a sample of retail sales data. The results favour these newly developed methods and provide some interesting insights for practical implementation.     

Time Series Modelling of Daily Tax Revenues

We provide a detailed discussion of time series modelling of daily data in general and daily tax revenues in particular. The main feature of the daily tax revenue series is the pattern within calendar months. Standard time series methods for seasonal adjustment and forecasting cannot be used since the number of banking days per calendar month varies and because there are two levels of seasonality: between months and within months. We propose a daily time series model based on unobserved components that allows for the classic decomposition into trend, seasonal plus irregular, but it also includes components for intra-monthly, trading-day and length-of-month effects. Such components typically rely on stochastic cubic spline, polynomial and dummy variable functions. State space techniques are used for the recursive computation of the likelihood and forecasts functions with special allowance for irregular spacing. The model is operational for daily forecasting at the Dutch Ministry of Finance. We present the model specification and discuss estimation and forecasting results up to December 1999. A comparative forecast evaluation is also presented.     

A note on the Robust Trend and ARARMA methodologies used in the M3 Competition

This brief note describes two of the forecasting methods used in the M3 Competition, Robust Trend and ARARMA. The origins of these methods are very different. Robust Trend was introduced to model the special features of some telecommunications time series. It was subsequently found to be competitive with Holt’s linear model for the more varied set of time series used in the M1 Competition. The ARARMA methodology was proposed by Parzen as a general time series modelling procedure, and can be thought of as an alternative to the ARIMA methodology of Box and Jenkins. This method was used in the M1 Competition and achieved the lowest mean absolute percentage error for longer forecasting horizons. These methods will be described in more detail and some comments on their use in the M3 Competition conclude this note.     

Implementation issues on shrinkage estimators for seasonal factors within the X-11 seasonal adjustment method

This commentary on Miller and Williams [Intl. J. Forecast. 20 (2004)S29-49] discusses how shrinkage can be implemented within X12-ARIMA. We discuss how the seasonal factors are estimated in X12-ARIMA, how shrinkage can be translated into a moving average, if this is compatible with the philosophy behind the X12-ARIMA method, and suggest possible improvements.     

Short-term forecasting of crime

The major question investigated is whether it is possible to accurately forecast selected crimes 1 month ahead in small areas, such as police precincts. In a case study of Pittsburgh, PA, we contrast the forecast accuracy of univariate time series models with naïve methods commonly used by police. A major result, expected for the small-scale data of this problem, is that average crime count by precinct is the major determinant of forecast accuracy. A fixed-effects regression model of absolute percent forecast error shows that such counts need to be on the order of 30 or more to achieve accuracy of 20% absolute forecast error or less. A second major result is that practically any model-based forecasting approach is vastly more accurate than current police practices. Holt exponential smoothing with monthly seasonality estimated using city-wide data is the most accurate forecast model for precinct-level crime series.     

Econometric Models and Economic Forecasting

This Briefing Paper is thejirst ofa series of three designeddiscussed is the process of making 'constant adjustments' in forecasts. This process involves modifying the results generated by the econometric model. For the first time we are publishing tables of the constant adjustments used in the current forecast. We explain in general why such adjustments are made and also explain the actual adjustments we have made for this forecast.
The second article of the series, to be published in our February 1983 edition, will describe the potential sources of error in forecasts. In particular it will describe the inevitable stochastic or random element involved in e tatistical attempts to quantify economic behaviour. As a completely new departure the article will report estimates of future errors based on stochastic simulations of the LBS. model and will provide statistical error bad for the main elements of the forecast.
The final article, to be published in our June 1983 edition, will contrast the measures of forecast error that e e obtain from the estimation process and our stochastic e imulationsp with the errors that we have actually made, as revealed by an examination of our forecasting 'track record'. It is hoped to draw, from this comparison, some e eneral conclusions about the scope and limits of econometric forecasting producers.     

A two-step approach for identifying seasonal autoregressive time series forecasting models

One of the most powerful and widely used methodologies for forecasting economic time series is the class of models known as seasonal autoregressive processes. In this article we present a new approach not only for identifying seasonal autoregressive models, but also the degree of differencing required to induce stationarity in the data. The identification method is iterative and consists in systematically fitting increasing order models to the data, and then verifying that the resulting residuals behave like white noise using a two stage autoregressive order determination criterion. Once the order of the process is determined the identified structure is tested to see if it can be simplified. The identification performance of this procedure is contrasted with other order selection procedures for models with ‘gaps.' We also illustrate the forecast performance of the identification method using monthly and quarterly economic data.     

Beyond point forecasting: Evaluation of alternative prediction intervals for tourist arrivals

This paper evaluates the performances of prediction intervals generated from alternative time series models, in the context of tourism forecasting. The forecasting methods considered include the autoregressive (AR) model, the AR model using the bias-corrected bootstrap, seasonal ARIMA models, innovations state space models for exponential smoothing, and Harvey’s structural time series models. We use thirteen monthly time series for the number of tourist arrivals to Hong Kong and Australia. The mean coverage rates and widths of the alternative prediction intervals are evaluated in an empirical setting. It is found that all models produce satisfactory prediction intervals, except for the autoregressive model. In particular, those based on the bias-corrected bootstrap perform best in general, providing tight intervals with accurate coverage rates, especially when the forecast horizon is long.     

The RWDAR model: A novel state-space approach to forecasting

This paper introduces the Random Walk with Drift plus AutoRegressive model (RWDAR) for time-series forecasting. Owing to the presence of a random walk plus drift term, this model shares some similarities with the Theta model of Assimakopoulos and Nikolopoulos (2000). However, the addition of a first-order autoregressive term in the state equation provides additional adaptability and flexibility. Indeed, it is shown that RWDAR tends to outperform the Theta model when forecasting both stationary and nearly non-stationary time series. This paper also proposes a simple estimation method for the RWDAR model based on the solution of the algebraic Riccati equation for the prediction error covariance of the state vector. Simulation results show that this estimator performs as well as the standard Kalman filter approach. Finally, using yearly data from the M3 and M4 competition datasets, it is found that RWDAR outperforms traditional forecasting methods.     

Predictive regressions under asymmetric loss: Factor augmentation and model selection

This paper discusses the specifics of forecasting using factor-augmented predictive regressions under general loss functions. In line with the literature, we employ principal component analysis to extract factors from the set of predictors. In addition, we also extract information on the volatility of the series to be predicted, since the volatility is forecast-relevant under non-quadratic loss functions. We ensure asymptotic unbiasedness of the forecasts under the relevant loss by estimating the predictive regression through the minimization of the in-sample average loss. Finally, we select the most promising predictors for the series to be forecast by employing an information criterion that is tailored to the relevant loss. Using a large monthly data set for the US economy, we assess the proposed adjustments in a pseudo out-of-sample forecasting exercise for various variables. As expected, the use of estimation under the relevant loss is found to be effective. Using an additional volatility proxy as the predictor and conducting model selection that is tailored to the relevant loss function enhances the forecast performance significantly.