Bayesian Risk Management for Equity-Linked Insurance

This paper describes how to apply Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) techniques to a regime switching model of the stock price process to generate a sample from the joint posterior distribution of the parameters of the model. The MCMC output can be used to generate a sample from the predictive distribution of losses from equity linked contracts, assuming first an actuarial approach to risk management and secondly a financial economics approach. The predictive distribution is used to show the effect of parameter uncertainty on risk management calculations. We also explore model uncertainty by assuming a GARCH model in place of the regime switching model. The results indicate that the financial economics approach to risk management is substantially more robust to parameter uncertainty and model uncertainty than the actuarial approach.     

The Evolving Role of the Actuary in Financial Reporting of Insurance

Abstract

The demands that financial reporting of insurance companies present to actuaries are great and growing. With the prospects of change in the rules for financial reporting becoming more likely and insurance products becoming more complex, it is desirable to examine the evolving roles of the actuary and the actuarial profession. This paper describes these changes and the value that actuaries bring to financial reporting. The challenges presented are significant. As the methods of assessing and managing risk change are becoming more complex, the best efforts of the profession and individual actuaries will be needed to ensure that the actuary’s role is enhanced and expanded. Not only will the techniques used evolve, but the audiences served by the actuary will become even more demanding. The actuarial profession is better situated than other professions to meet these demands.     

The DB Underpin Hybrid Pension Plan

Abstract

In this paper the defined benefit underpin guarantee is valued as a financial option, within the traditional funding paradigms of actuarial science. Assuming fixed interest rates, and assuming that salaries can be treated as a tradable asset, we value the guarantee using fair value principles. Contribution rates are developed for the Entry Age Normal, Projected Unit Credit, and Traditional Unit Credit funding methods. In addition, for the accruals methods, we demonstrate the implied hedging strategy. The traditional unit credit offers the best method of these three, as it is consistent with the principles of financial economics, and the resulting contributions more naturally follow the cost of the emerging benefit, without creating expensive barriers to new hires. The method generates significant contribution volatility, and we demonstrate how this can be reduced with suitable benefit design and ongoing risk management.     

Measuring Terminable Postretirement Obligations

Abstract

New approaches are needed to value benefit plans subject to unilateral changes or termination. The paper focuses on postretirement health benefits, but the thesis may be relevant to any flow not guaranteed by law or accumulating funds.

Retiree health benefits have usually been extended to participating active employees only in concert with a reserved right by the plan sponsor to control the design and, by implication, the cash flow. Over the course of the last fifteen years, this reserved extension of benefits has almost invariably led to reductions in benefits, when compared to the plan of benefits at an earlier period. In most cases, such reductions were anticipated under the circumstances that came to prevail (high health care cost increases), but were not taken into account by most of the projection and discounting methods of the time.

Current actuarial and accounting methods generate present values for terminable retiree health plans that have little credibility as measures of the beneficiary’s asset or the sponsor’s liability. Improvements are needed that will expand the actuarial toolbox and provide solutions to economic and accounting problems.

This paper provides a basis for discussion of assumptions that are appropriate when the plan sponsor can unilaterally and dramatically change future cash flows. The paper discusses how actuaries might best approach measurement situations where further plan reductions, or outright terminations, are to be anticipated. It introduces refinements and briefly discusses how each would fit with the usual actuarial model and how differences might affect behavior. These ideas are related to financial economics and the Bader-Gold paper “Reinventing Pension Actuarial Science.” Before concluding, the wider topic of discount rate selection is briefly addressed.     

Stochastic Models for Continuing Care Retirement Communities

Abstract

Continuing care retirement communities (CCRCs) offer housing and a variety of services, including long-term care. Typically, the cost of this long-term care is wholly or partially covered by entry and/or periodic fees. Thus, CCRCs provide a long-term-care insurance benefit. For this and other reasons, actuarial involvement in the financial management of CCRCs is desirable. To carry out actuarial analyses of CCRCs, appropriate models are required to describe the status of individual residents and the CCRC population.

This paper presents models that assume that, at any time, a resident is in a given “state,” which is determined by the individual’s care requirements. The resident may make “transitions” between states at various times, and randomness is associated with both the transition times and the states entered. Actuarial calculations using such a model are discussed, and numerical illustrations are provided. A simple model is examined first; then generalizations are considered. The model for an individual resident can be embedded in a model for a CCRC population. This is explored with particular attention given to the “high-demand” situation in which potential residents are always waiting to enter the community. With this model, the goal is to analyze the future care requirements of the CCRC population.     

Pension Funds and the U.K. Economy

Abstract

The paper considers the impact of U.K. defined benefit (DB) pension plan unding and investment on the U.K. economy. It suggests that many conventional theories are based on incomplete or inconsistent economics. In particular, the author suggests that:

? An economy cannot really gain competitive advantage from high returns on the domestic assets in which pension funds invest.

? DB liabilities are essentially similar for most schemes and can be closely matched with bonds.

? Funding pension liabilities has no primary impact on individuals’ consumption and saving or on firms’ capital investment.

? Pension funds are not natural investors in the equity of new ventures.

The conclusion of the paper is that the most significant impact of pension funds on the U.K. economy relates to the costs imposed by extreme mismatching between their financial assets and liabilities. The author argues that such risks can, in essence, “crowd out” entrepreneurial risk. He asserts that the U.K. economy would gain from greater focus on the matching of these assets and liabilities, and that the best way to stimulate enterprise is by eliminating the frictional costs in the economy arising from current practices.     

Basic concepts in life assurance mathematics

Abstract

1. Introduction.

In this paper the basic concepts of the life insurance mathematics will be discussed. Due to the fact that the importance of the probability calculus as a hasis for the actuarial science has repeatedly been disclaimed in recent literature (See e.g. Ernst ZWinggi (1]), the present author feels that there is a justification for reconsidering the fundamental ideas of the actuarial science.     

The Earnings Implications of Pension Expense

Abstract

Recent challenges to the actuarial pension model and a movement to harmonize international accounting standards both suggest that the current Canadian standards for pension accounting, CICA 3461, may see substantial revision during upcoming years. To understand better the implications of these possible accounting changes, this paper presents the results of a stochastic analysis that quantifies how the volatility of pension expense for a sample of ten Canadian companies sponsoring defined benefit plans will be increased by the adoption of immediate recognition accounting. For certain companies this increase is significant and is shown to have a material earnings impact. The implications of this earnings volatility for the future of defined benefit pension plans are also explored.     

An Actuarial Premium Pricing Model for Nonnormal Insurance and Financial Risks in Incomplete Markets

Abstract

A model for pricing insurance and financial risks, based on recent developments in actuarial premium principles with elliptical distributions, is developed for application to incomplete markets and heavy-tailed distributions. The pricing model involves an application of a generalized variance premium principle from insurance pricing to the pricing of a portfolio of nontraded risks relative to a portfolio of traded risks. This pricing model for a portfolio of insurance or financial risks reflects preferences for features of the distributions other than mean and variance, including kurtosis. The model reduces to the Capital Asset Pricing Model for multinormal portfolios and to a form of the CAPM in the case where the traded and nontraded risks have the same elliptical distribution.     

Översikt av utländska aktuarietidskrifter

Abstract

In this paper a continuous-time model of a reinsurance market is presented, which contains the principal components of uncertainty transparent in such a market: Uncertainty about the time instants at which accidents take place, and uncertainty about claim sizes given that accidents have occurred.

Due to random jumps at random time points of the underlying claims processes, the absence of arbitrage opportunities is not sufficient to give unique premium functionals in general. Market preferences are derived under a necessary condition for a general exchange equilibrium. Information constraints are found under which premiums of risks are determined. It is demonstrated how general reinsurance treaties can be uniquely split into proportional contracts and nonproportional ones.

Several applications to reinsurance markets are given, and the results are compared to the corresponding theory of the classical one-period model of a reinsurance syndicate.

This paper attempts to reach a synthesis between the classical actuarial risk theory of insurance, in which virtually no economic reasoning takes place but where the net reserve is represented by a stochastic process, and the theory of partial equilibrium price formation at the heart of the economics of uncertainty.     

Pricing Weather Derivatives Using the Indifference Pricing Approach

Abstract

This paper adopts an incomplete market pricing model–the indifference pricing approach–to analyze valuation of weather derivatives and the viability of the weather derivatives market in a hedging context. It incorporates price risk, weather/quantity risk, and other risks in the financial market. In a mean-variance framework, the relationship between the actuarial price and the indifference price of weather derivatives is analyzed, and conditions are obtained concerning when the actuarial price does not provide an appropriate valuation for weather derivatives. Conditions for the viability of the weather derivatives market are examined. This paper also analyzes the effects of partial hedging, natural hedges, basis risk, quantity risk, and price risk on investors’ indifference prices by examining the distributional impacts of the stochastic variables involved.     

The Role and Current Status of IFRS in the Completion of National Accounting Rules – Evidence from Turkey

Abstract

As it is not a member of the European Union, Turkey has not yet adopted EU accounting directives by law. Instead, Turkish standard setting authority adopted International Financial Reporting Standards for entities that have public accountability and has recently prepared the draft Turkish financial reporting standard for non-publicly accountable entities that are subject to independent audit: Framework for Local Financial Reporting. This national standard is influenced by European accounting directive 2013/34, international financial reporting practices and UK experience in addition to national accounting rules.     

Integration of Financial Services

Abstract

Integration financial services is a term with many meanings. Definitions might include:

• ownership of different segments of financial services,

• the distribution of products of one segment by another, and

• a consumer-centric strategy driven to satisfy the needs of the customer regardless of organizational structures.

For the purposes of my paper, I will define it as the erasing of boundaries leading to consumers receiving value propositions that are not restricted by traditional industry segment barriers.     

Overview

Abstract

From the inception of Social Security in 1935 to the present time, a variety of measures for evaluating the actuarial status of the program have been employed. In addition, how the results of these measures have been displayed and interpreted has also evolved. These results have had great influence on policymakers’ and the general public’s perceptions of the financial condition of the program. This paper is intended to be an update of my earlier paper on the same subject, that is, a historical review of the development of these methods and their interpretation. The paper closes with suggestions as to future changes in the measurement methods, in the light of possible future changes in the program itself.     

Fuzzy Financial Pricing of Property-Liability Insurance

Abstract

This paper uses fuzzy set theory (FST) to solve a problem in actuarial science, the financial pricing of property-liability insurance contracts. The fundamental concept of FST is the alternative formalization of membership in a set to include the degree or strength of membership. FST provides consistent mathematical rules for incorporating vague, subjective, or judgmental information into complex decision processes. It is potentially important in insurance pricing because much of the information about cash flows, future economic conditions, risk premiums, and other factors affecting the pricing decision is subjective and thus difficult to quantify by using conventional methods. To illustrate the use of FST, we “fuzzify” a well-known insurance financial pricing model, provide numerical examples of fuzzy pricing, and propose rules for project decision-making using FST. The results indicate that FST can lead to significantly different decisions than the conventional approach.     

Robust and Efficient Estimation of the Tail Index of a Single-Parameter Pareto Distribution

Abstract

Estimation of the tail index parameter of a single-parameter Pareto model has wide application in actuarial and other sciences. Here we examine various estimators from the standpoint of two competing criteria: efficiency and robustness against upper outliers. With the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) being efficient but nonrobust, we desire alternative estimators that retain a relatively high degree of efficiency while also being adequately robust. A new generalized median type estimator is introduced and compared with the MLE and several well-established estimators associated with the methods of moments, trimming, least squares, quantiles, and percentile matching. The method of moments and least squares estimators are found to be relatively deficient with respect to both criteria and should become disfavored, while the trimmed mean and generalized median estimators tend to dominate the other competitors. The generalized median type performs best overall. These findings provide a basis for revision and updating of prevailing viewpoints. Other topics discussed are applications to robust estimation of upper quantiles, tail probabilities, and actuarial quantities, such as stop-loss and excess-of-loss reinsurance premiums that arise concerning solvency of portfolios. Robust parametric methods are compared with empirical nonparametric methods, which are typically nonrobust.     

The Actuary’s Role in Managed Care

Abstract

Financial risk is moving to center stage in the $1-trillion U.S. health-care market. The growth of managed care has created new forms of risk and has shifted this risk from insurance companies, which have long dealt with it successfully, to health-care providers and other organizations that have not traditionally accepted the same type and amount of risk. Health-care actuaries have the expertise to help these institutions, and the nation, protect their financial well-being.

Actuaries specialize in the evaluation, quantification, and management of risk. Actuarial models of health-care costs, which help evaluate risk, offer management a window to the managed care world. With these models and other tools, health-care actuaries help organizations succeed in today’s health-care environment by showing how the financial and functional elements of an organization relate to risk.

This report discusses the evolution of the health-care industry and the role that the healthcare actuary has played in that evolution. Eight case studies outline actuarial approaches to assessing risk in the era of managed care by discussing situations affecting five groups: providers, employers, regulators, public policy organizations, and HMOs. Built on experience gained in hundreds of cases, these studies show the range of tasks encountered by managed care actuaries and outline approaches that can help balance risks in today’s health-care system.     

Risk and Discounted Loss Reserves

Abstract

The author places the discounting of loss reserves for investment income within a financial economics context. This enables the evaluation of a loss reserve containing a security margin, such as to produce p% confidence in adequacy, taking account of both asset and liability risks. This loss reserve is expressed as a multiple of the economic value of the liabilities. If the security margin is defined as the difference between these two quantities, it is found to increase (decrease) withincreasing asset risk for high (low) values of p. Finally, the author provides a numerical example.     

Fair valuation of insurance liabilities via mean-variance hedging in a multi-period setting

A general class of fair valuations which are both market-consistent (mark-to-market for any hedgeable part of a claim) and actuarial (mark-to-model for any claim that is independent of financial market evolutions) was introduced in Dhaene et al. [Insurance: Mathematics & Economics, 76, 14–27 (2017)] in a single period framework. In particular, the authors considered mean-variance hedge-based (MVHB) valuations where fair valuations of insurance liabilities are expressed in terms of mean-variance hedges and actuarial valuations. In this paper, we generalize this MVHB approach to a multi-period dynamic investment setting. We show that the classes of fair valuations and MVHB valuations are equivalent in this generalized setting. We derive tractable formulas for the fair valuation of equity-linked contracts and show how the actuarial part of their MVHB valuation decomposes into a diversifiable and a non-diversifiable component.     

Principal Applications of Bayesian Methods in Actuarial Science

Abstract

Bayesian ideas were introduced into actuarial science in the late 1960s in the form of empirical credibility methods for premium setting. The advance of the Bayesian methodology was slow due to its subjective nature and to the computational difficulties associated with the full Bayesian analysis. This paper offers a brief survey of Bayesian solutions to some actuarial problems and discusses the current state of research.