红学是不是学术，该不该成为显学？——兼与王文元研究员商榷

学术的评判标准是其研究有没有形成一个专业性强的复杂系统，红学的学术性质具体体现在其学科体系上。《红楼梦》是曹雪芹利用他一生（从幼到老）的生活素材，精心建造的雄伟的金碧辉煌的皇宫，我们可以通过对这一皇宫的研究来还原其生活素材，去寻找标准答案。红学成为显学决不是“完全是人为造势的结果”，它主要是“自然选择”的结果。红学发展必须建立在对大量红学附会的纠正上，如果没有这些附会的存在，今天红学不可能有这么快的发展。红学的效益性在其研究的服务性即能否转化为现实生产力，这也是红学的主道。人民群众的正统思想是追求自由、追求自身解放、追求全面发展的思想，这是历史发展的主道，红学的主道也不能偏离历史发展的主道。

Is the Dream of Red Mansions Academic or not？ Should the School Become Sigpificant？ ——Discussion with Researcher WANG Wen-yuan

Academic standard for judging a study is whether or not a strong professional complex system is formed. The specific academic nature of Rod Mansions is embodied in its disciplines system. ＂Dream of the ROd Chamber＂ was carefully built as a grand majestic palaces by Cao Xueqin using his life materials （from young to old）. We can use the palace to restore his material life, and find the disciplines standard answers. The prominence of the academic school absolutely is not the result of ＂completely artificial manufacture＂, but ＂natural selection＂. The development of the school must be based on a large number of Red Mansions corrections. If no existence of these school, there will be no so fast development. The effectiveness of the school embodies in its service of studying that can translate into real productive forces, and it also is the main road of the school. People＇s orthodox ideology is the thought of seeking for freedom, pursuing their own liberation and all - round development, this is the main path of historical development. The main stem of the school development can not be deviated from the main road of the historical development.