Heterogeneous Beliefs, the Term Structure and Time-varying Risk Premia

This paper demonstrates theoretically and empirically that one possible economic explanation of the dynamics of the term structure of interest rates is the time-varying heterogeneous beliefs about future economic conditions. Assuming that each agent forms heterogeneous expectations about both his income shock and others’ beliefs about their income shocks each period, the paper illustrates that heterogeneous beliefs generate time-varying risk premia of the term structure in a closed-form solution. Motivated by this theory, several empirical tests are conducted using the cross-sectional mean and dispersion of belief indices that are extracted as the differences between non-judgemental econometric forecasts based on diffusion indices in Stock and Watson (J Bus Econ Stat, 2002) and professional survey forecasts. It is shown that (a) an increase in the mean belief about inflation steepens the yield curve, (b) the mean and dispersion of interest rate beliefs help explain the mean and the stochastic volatility of the term structure, suggesting that time-varying risk premia may be explained by endogenous uncertainty caused by heterogeneous beliefs in the economy.I am indebted to Mordecai Kurz, Timothy Cogley and Narayana Kocherlakota for constant support and extensive discussions that inspired this work. I would like to thank Randall Moore for providing the Blue Chip financial forecast data. The financial support from the Smith Richardson Foundation to the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research is gratefully acknowledged.