Regression analysis on the variation in efficiency frontiers for prevention stage of HIV/AIDS

Abstract

Objectives:

To investigate how the cost effectiveness of preventing HIV/AIDS varies across possible efficiency frontiers (EFs) by taking into account potentially relevant external factors, such as prevention stage, and how the EFs can be characterized using regression analysis given uncertainty of the QALY-cost estimates.

Methods:

We reviewed cost-effectiveness estimates for the prevention and treatment of HIV/AIDS published from 2002–2007 and catalogued in the Tufts Medical Center Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (CEA) Registry. We constructed efficiency frontier (EF) curves by plotting QALYs against costs, using methods used by the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) in Germany. We stratified the QALY-cost ratios by prevention stage, country of study, and payer perspective, and estimated EF equations using log and square-root models.

Results:

A total of 53 QALY-cost ratios were identified for HIV/AIDS in the Tufts CEA Registry. Plotted ratios stratified by prevention stage were visually grouped into a cluster consisting of primary/secondary prevention measures and a cluster consisting of tertiary measures. Correlation coefficients for each cluster were statistically significant. For each cluster, we derived two EF equations – one based on the log model, and one based on the square-root model.

Discussion:

Our findings indicate that stratification of HIV/AIDS interventions by prevention stage can yield distinct EFs, and that the correlation and regression analyses are useful for parametrically characterizing EF equations. Our study has certain limitations, such as the small number of included articles and the potential for study populations to be non-representative of countries of interest. Nonetheless, our approach could help develop a deeper appreciation of cost effectiveness beyond the deterministic approach developed by IQWiG.     

HIV/AIDS in eastern and southern Africa

"This article reviews some recent key books on HIV/AIDS in Africa. It does so by examining the debates relating to the extent and possible future development of HIV/AIDS referring to the discussions about demographic, economic and social impacts in especially eastern and southern Africa. It explores the so-called doomsday scenarios and addresses themes linked to the important and increasing attention being paid to the gendered aspects of HIV/AIDS."     

A cost-benefit analysis of female primary education as a means of reducing HIV/AIDS in Tanzania

This article, uses panel data related to 20 Tanzania regions and 8 years to estimate the direct and indirect effects of female primary education on HIV/AIDS rates. A recursive framework for education, income and infections is employed, based on two autoregressive equations that allow us to obtain dynamic estimates of effectiveness. We find that the indirect effect working through changes in income outweighs the direct positive effect of education on infections, implying that female education can be effective as an intervention to lower the disease in Tanzania. The estimates of effectiveness are then utilized to carry out a cost-benefit analysis of the education expenditures. The human capital approach is used to measure the benefits. Irrespective of the timing of the benefits and costs, and the discount rate alternatives we consider, our best estimates result in positive net-benefits, with benefit-cost ratios in the range 1.3–2.9.     

Pricing and patents of HIV/AIDS drugs in developing countries

This article provides empirical evidence on the impact of patents on drug prices across developing countries. It uses sales data on human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)/acquired immuno deficiency syndrome (AIDS) drugs in a sample of 34 low- and middle-income countries between 1995 and mid-2000. The main findings are that patents do shift drug prices up, drug prices are correlated to per capita income levels and drug firms follow a skimming strategy when pricing new HIV/AIDS drugs. That is, there is across country and intertemporal price discrimination in the global drug markets.     

Effect of HIV/AIDS on Economic Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa: Recent Evidence

International Advances in Economic Research - This paper examines the effect of human immunodeficiency virus/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (HIV/AIDS) on economic growth in sub-Saharan Africa...     

Economic growth and disease in the OLG model: The HIV/AIDS case

The aim of this paper is to provide an analysis of the impact of investment in health-policies on economic development. In order to do this, it is vital to bear in mind the fact that long-term economic growth is characterized by the interaction between the physical aspects of capital dynamics and the disease level in a developing country which lacks a financial market. The OLG model will be used in our analysis. Notice that the level of investment in health policies and disease management are one of the key variables of the model. It is, therefore, interesting to observe that an increase in capital may have either a direct or indirect impact on the stationary disease level and lead to effective prevention and disease control.     

Risky Sex in a Risky World: Sexual Behavior in an HIV/AIDS Environment

In spite of increased awareness of HIV/AIDS, unprotected casual sex is still widespread in many HIV‐infected countries. In this paper, a two‐period model for sexual decisions under uncertainty is developed. The results suggest that, for individuals with limited access to HIV treatment, the uncertainty about their future health could be an important factor driving unsafe sexual practices. The results support the empirical finding of a weak link in poor countries between sexual behavior, HIV frequency, and HIV knowledge. Therefore, this suggests that an AIDS policy needs to be calibrated in order to fit within different social contexts.     

某低流行地区1995～2012年艾滋病疫情流行特征分析

目的了解1995～2012年某低流行地区艾滋病疫情流行特征,为今后当地预防控制艾滋病提供科学依据。方法根据中国疾病预防控制信息系统中的艾滋病综合防治信息的上报数据,对1995～2012年报告的艾滋病病毒感染者/艾滋病病人( HIV/AIDS)的资料进行流行病学分析。结果1995～2012年累计报告HIV/AIDS104例,其中男性83例,女性21例,男性明显高于女性;职业分布以农民和工人为主,占78.7%;高发年龄为20～49年龄组,占86.5%。感染者文化程度以初中及以下为主,占62.5%;传播途径以性传播为主,占80.9%;自2007年以来,报告病例数逐渐增多。结论该地区疫情仍处于低流行地区,2007年以来,感染人数逐年增多,感染人数主要集中在文化程度低的男性青壮年农民（农民工）,性途径是最主要的传播途径,男男性行为传播上升明显。     

铁默斯预言：人血买卖与艾滋病的孪生关系

本文集中分析我国1990年—1995年间出现的人血买卖市场与艾滋病流行的关系。作者首先讨论英国社会学家理查德·铁默斯早在1970年就针对血液买卖发出的警告以及他为什么将无偿献血视为“生命赠予”,随后回顾了我国血液买卖的历史并提出我国有偿供血现象背后是立法者和政策制定者对中国老百姓的公益精神之怀疑。否则,中国就不会出现一大批由于有偿的血液买卖而感染艾滋病的受难者。艾滋病病毒主要通过血液传播,二十世纪九十年代初人血买卖市场的猖獗助长了我国艾滋病疫情的快速发展,这是一种孪生关系。     

An analysis of production efficiency differentials in the Philippines

In the late seventies and early eighties, policy makers in many developing encouraged extensive research to develop appropriate rice technology for unfavourable rainfed environments. The question addressed in this paper is whether the farmers producing under the non-irrigated rainfed environments are achieving the potential of the technology fully at the farm level. The empirical analysis which concerns the farm-level production behaviour of rainfed rice farmers in the Philippines indicates a wide variation in production efficiencies. Extension advice and credit availability appear to be the two major factors influencing the gap between farmers' actual and potential production levels.     

How does the impact of an HIV/AIDS information campaign vary with educational attainment? Evidence from rural Uganda

The responsiveness to information is thought to be one channel through which education affects health outcomes. This paper tests this hypothesis by examining the effectiveness of an information campaign that aims at preventing the HIV/AIDS epidemic in Uganda. It uses individual level data from a cohort study following and testing the general population of a cluster of villages in rural Uganda over 12 years and shows that, after more than a decade of prevention campaigns about the dangers of the epidemic, there has been a substantial evolution in the HIV/education gradient. Early in the epidemic, in 1990, there was no robust relation between HIV/AIDS and education. In 2000, among young females, education is associated with a lower risk of being HIV positive. Results on HIV incidence in a duration framework confirm that finding by establishing that, for young women, education reduces the probability of seroconversion. These findings reveal that educated women have been more responsive to the HIV/AIDS information campaigns. The analysis of sexual behavior reinforces that conclusion: condom use is associated positively with schooling levels.     

HIV／AIDS防治中的医患交往艺术——一个景颇村寨中的信任表达

本世纪以来,中国各艾滋病重度流行地区的防治运动往往面临着过度“行政依赖”的制度困境,然而,本文在中国西南边境线上的一个景颇村寨中发现了例外。当地的官方防疫体制通过在终端启用代理人——乡村医生——来进行实际干预,极大规避了阳性群体对于防疫体制的过度依赖,以及由此造成的消极的社会道德后果。来自田野的事实证明,围绕着防疫实践的医患交往在信任机制的组织下,不仅柔和了官方防疫体制与对象间的文化张力,还通过策略而技巧的实践过程增强了对阳性人群的控制能力,并反过来强化了医患间的信任纽带。总的来说,医患间的交往艺术让医学权力的运作得以情境化,实现了社会控制的本意。     

我国银行业市场结构与效率变迁实证分析

在过去的10年中,我国银行业的内外部环境发生了很大的变化,银行业市场结构和经营效率的相应变化是文章试图解答的问题。通过实证检验发现,在过去的10年中银行业市场集中度整体呈下降之势,竞争的加剧促进了银行效率的提高。因此,现阶段竞争程度的上升有助于推动银行业效率的提高。     

An analysis of the impact of unionization on efficiency: evidence from a meta-frontier analysis

This article examines the impact of unions on the efficiency of establishments in the manufacturing industry by comparing the results from two different empirical strategies: stochastic frontier analysis (SFA) and meta-frontier analysis (MFA). While SFA concludes that union establishments show higher technological efficiency, the results are the opposite when estimating production functions with MFA. In SFA, unionized establishments appear to be more efficient because they remain closer to their own production frontier; however, in MFA – where groups with heterogeneous technology can be compared – we find that nonunionized establishments are more efficient because they are closer to the meta-frontier than their unionized counterparts.     

Daily variation,capital market efficiency and predicting stock returns for the Hong Kong and Tokyo exchanges

Studying capital market efficiency is important because result may infer that there are predictable properties of the time series of prices of traded securities on organized markets. We examine the weak form of the efficient markets hypothesis to indicate its usefulness in terms of the results of this study. Furthermore, this study of individual securities prices of traded securities on the organized markets of Hong Kong and Japan corroborate previous findings of studies of individual stocks and market indexes both in Asian nations, the United States and other stock exchanges in the United Kingdom and Europe. Daily patterns are present in the times series of securities prices. You will note also, that the models identified reflect the returns on individual firms listed on the two of the three largest Asian Stock Exchanges.     

中国工业部门能源使用效率及其影响因素研究

本文对我国工业部门的全要素能源使用效率进行了测算,结果表明,考察期内全部样本行业的能效均值基本维持在50%至60%水平之间,能效水平总体不高.能源使用效率存在着较为显著的行业间差异,采掘业能效水平均值要高于轻工业和重工业.总体能效水平以2002年为拐点,出现了先上升后下降的变化轨迹.采掘业能效水平在考察期内有所波动,但基本能够维持在相对较高水平,重工业呈缓慢上升态势,而轻工业则在2002年以后出现了大幅下降.通过计算标准差,我们也未发现能效出现行业趋同.企业平均规模的扩大、市场竞争强度的降低、外资规模的增加对行业能效提高具有积极影响.     

The influence analysis on public expenditure to the technique efficiency of China

In this paper, we use SFA to estimate the time-variant stochastic frontier model of 31 cities in China. The results tell us that raising the proportion of public expenditure in GDP can lower the technological efficiency, but raising some parts of public expenditure in GDP can promote the technological efficiency. Its realistic meaning is that it is excellent to turn the public expenditure structure to promote the technological efficiency. We computed the technological efficiency of 31 provinces/cities and the results show that the gap between the eastern region and western region is growing much. Finally, we decompose total factor productivity (TFP) and get the following result: from three regions, the biggest influence factor on technological efficiency is the scales economy. Technological progress and allocation efficiency have a smaller influence. From our results, we suggest that technological progress and allocation efficiency from public expenditure and income be raised to influence the TFP rate of change, and have a more efficient public expenditure. __________ Translated from Journal of Finance and Economics (财经研究), 2005, (12) (in Chinese)