Semiparametric Estimator for Binary‐outcome Sample Selection: Prejudice Matters in Election

a semiparametric estimator for binary‐outcome sample‐selection models is proposed that imposes only single index assumptions on the selection and outcome equations without specifying the error term distribution. I adopt the idea in Lewbel (2000) using a ‘special regressor’ to transform the binary response Y so that the transformed Y becomes linear in the latent index, which then makes it possible to remove the selection correction term by differencing the transformed Y equation. There are various versions of the estimator, which perform differently trading off bias and variance. A simulation study is conducted, and then I apply the estimators to US presidential election data in 2008 and 2012 to assess the impact of racial prejudice on the elections, as a black candidate was involved for the first time ever in the US history.     

On bootstrapping the mode in the nonparametric regression model with random design

In the nonparametric regression model with random design and based on i.i.d. pairs of observations (X _i, Y _i), where the regression function m is given by m(x)=?(Y _i|X _i=x), estimation of the location θ (mode) of a unique maximum of m by the location of a maximum of the Nadaraya-Watson kernel estimator for the curve m is considered. In order to obtain asymptotic confidence intervals for θ, the suitably normalized distribution of is bootstrapped in two ways: we present a paired bootstrap (PB) where resampling is done from the empirical distribution of the pairs of observations and a smoothed paired bootstrap (SPB) where the bootstrap variables are generated from a smooth bivariate density based on the pairs of observations. While the PB requires only relatively small computational effort when carried out in practice, it is shown to work only in the case of vanishing asymptotic bias, i.e. of “undersmoothing” when compared to optimal smoothing for mode estimation. On the other hand, the SPB, although causing more intricate computations, is able to capture the correct amount of bias if the pilot estimator for m oversmoothes. Received: May 2000     

On Some Nonparametric Tests of Dispersion

Let X and Y be random variables with distribution functions F and G and medians ζand η, respectively. X will be said to be more dispersed about the median than Y if F(x+ζ) – F(–x+ζ) G (x+η) – G (–x+η)for all x > O, with sharp inequality holding for some positive x. Asymptotically nonparametric tests for the hypothesis that F (x+ζ) = G (x+η) against alternatives of the above type (for ζ and η unknown), provided F(x+ζ) (but not necessarily G (x+η)) is symmetric and Fand G have bounded densities, are constructed from a subclass Of SUKHATME'S modified generalized U - statistics [12]. One simple test of this subclass turns out to be the MANN-WHITNEY test as performed on the |X_i–ζ| and | Y_j–η| where ζ and η are the corresponding sample medians. Consistency and PITMAN efficiencies of some of the tests proposed are discussed under two families of alternatives in which the Y's differ from the X's through departure from symmetry as well as by being more (less) dispersed: a model of “heterogeneous response” and the wellknown gross error model. The usual scale alternatives are also studied and the relationship of our tests to those previously given in the literature is pointed out.     

Does more calculus improve student learning in intermediate micro- and macroeconomic theory?

Using a selection bias correction model with ordered probit, we estimate how a second semester of calculus affects students' grades in intermediate economic theory. Selection bias correction is needed because similar aptitudes and interests often lead students to enroll and do well in both mathematics and economics. A sample of students enrolled in 49 classes of intermediate micro and 41 classes of intermediate macro is used to estimate the model. The results show a predicted payoff from a second semester of calculus of about one whole letter grade in intermediate micro, but no payoff in intermediate macro. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Nonparametric efficiency analysis: A multivariate conditional quantile approach

This paper focuses on nonparametric efficiency analysis based on robust estimation of partial frontiers in a complete multivariate setup (multiple inputs and multiple outputs). It introduces α-quantile efficiency scores. A nonparametric estimator is proposed achieving strong consistency and asymptotic normality. Then if α increases to one as a function of the sample size we recover the properties of the FDH estimator. But our estimator is more robust to the perturbations in data, since it attains a finite gross-error sensitivity. Environmental variables can be introduced to evaluate efficiencies and a consistent estimator is proposed. Numerical examples illustrate the usefulness of the approach.     

A nonparametric approach to assess undergraduate performance

Nonparametric methodologies are proposed to assess college students' performance. Emphasis is given to gender and sector of high school. The application concerns the University of Campinas, a research university in Southeast Brazil. In Brazil college studies are based on a somewhat rigid set of subjects for each major. For this reason a simple GPA comparison may hide true performance. Therefore, we define individual vectors of course grades. These vectors are used in pairwise comparisons of common subject grades for individuals who entered college in the same year. The relative college performances of any two students are compared with their relative performances on the entrance exam score. A procedure based on generalized U-statistics is developed to test if there is selection bias in the entrance exam by some predefined groups, which is equipped with asymptotically normal distribution under both null and alternative hypotheses. Maximum power is attained by employing the union intersection principle, and resampling techniques such as nonparametric bootstrap are employed to generate the empirical distribution of the test statistics and get p-values.     

Replacing Sample Trimming with Boundary Correction in Nonparametric Estimation of First‐Price Auctions

Two‐step nonparametric estimators have become standard in empirical auctions. A drawback concerns boundary effects which cause inconsistencies near the endpoints of the support and bias in finite samples. To cope, sample trimming is typically used, which leads to non‐random data loss. Monte Carlo experiments show this leads to poor performance near the support boundaries and on the interior due to bandwidth selection issues. We propose a modification that employs boundary correction techniques, and we demonstrate substantial improvement in finite‐sample performance. We implement the new estimator using oil lease auctions data and find that trimming masks a substantial degree of bidder asymmetry and inefficiency in allocations. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The nonrandom selection of don't knows in binary and ordinal responses: Corrections with the bivariate probit model with sample selection

On social surveysdon't knows are a common answer to attitudinal questions, which often have binary or ordinal response categories.Don't knows can be nonrandomly selected according to certain demographic or socioeconomic characteristics of the respondent. To model the sample selection and correct for its bias, this paper discusses two types of bivariate models —binary-probit and the ordinal probit model with sample selection. The difference between parameter estimates and predicted probabilities from the analysis modelling the sample selection bias ofdon't knows and those from the analysis not modellingdon't knows is emphasized. Two empirical examples using the 1989 General Social Survey data demonstrate the necessity to correct for the bias in the nonrandom selection ofdon't knows for binary and ordinal attitudinal response variables. A replication of the analyses using the 1990 and 1991 General Social Survey data helps demonstrate the reliability of the sample selection bias ofdon't knows.     

Rank tests for testing randomness of a regression coefficient in a linear regression model

We propose a class of nonparametric tests for testing non-stochasticity of the regression parameterβ in the regression modely _i =βx _i +ɛ _i ,i=1, ...,n. We prove that the test statistics are asymptotically normally distributed both underH ₀ and under contiguous alternatives. The asymptotic relative efficiencies (in the Pitman sense) with respect to the best parametric test have also been computed and they are quite high. Some simulation studies are carried out to illustrate the results. Research was supported by the University Grants Commission, India.     

BANKING SECTOR PERFORMANCE,PROFITABILITY, AND EFFICIENCY: A CITATION-BASED SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW

This study presents a citation-based systematic literature review on banking sector performance, particularly in terms of profitability, productivity, and efficiency. Specifically, the study aims to identify the leading sources of knowledge in terms of the most influential journals, authors, and papers. The paper presents a content analysis of the 100 most cited papers. In total, 1996 peer-review papers were found relevant in the Scopus database by using a comprehensive list of keywords. The results show that the Journal of Banking & Finance appears to be the leading journal in terms of publication count and citations. Based on total citations, Allen Berger is the most prolific author. The most cited paper is “Problem loans and cost efficiency in commercial banks” by Allan Berger and Robert DeYoung. The content analysis of the top 100 papers identifies five essential themes: determinants of efficiency, methodology, ownership, financial crises, and scale economies. In terms of estimation approaches, 74% of papers employed frontier analysis, which includes 34% parametric and 40% nonparametric methods, and remaining 26% have used financial ratio analysis. Additionally, stochastic frontier and data envelopment analysis are widely used in parametric and nonparametric methods, respectively. An intermediate approach is extensively adopted for the specification of inputs and outputs.     

Local multiplicative bias correction for asymmetric kernel density estimators

We consider semiparametric asymmetric kernel density estimators when the unknown density has support on [0,∞)$[0,\infty )$. We provide a unifying framework which relies on a local multiplicative bias correction, and contains asymmetric kernel versions of several semiparametric density estimators considered previously in the literature. This framework allows us to use popular parametric models in a nonparametric fashion and yields estimators which are robust to misspecification. We further develop a specification test to determine if a density belongs to a particular parametric family. The proposed estimators outperform rival non- and semiparametric estimators in finite samples and are easy to implement. We provide applications to loss data from a large Swiss health insurer and Brazilian income data.     

Exponent of Cross‐Sectional Dependence: Estimation and Inference

This paper provides a characterisation of the degree of cross‐sectional dependence in a two dimensional array, {x_it,i = 1,2,...N;t = 1,2,...,T} in terms of the rate at which the variance of the cross‐sectional average of the observed data varies with N. Under certain conditions this is equivalent to the rate at which the largest eigenvalue of the covariance matrix of x _t=(x_1t,x_2t,...,x_Nt)′ rises with N. We represent the degree of cross‐sectional dependence by α, which we refer to as the ‘exponent of cross‐sectional dependence’, and define it by the standard deviation, , where is a simple cross‐sectional average of x_it. We propose bias corrected estimators, derive their asymptotic properties for α > 1/2 and consider a number of extensions. We include a detailed Monte Carlo simulation study supporting the theoretical results. We also provide a number of empirical applications investigating the degree of inter‐linkages of real and financial variables in the global economy. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Optimal Social Design: Estimating a Social Welfare Function from Questionnaire Data

A social design x evokes a response y from a set of individuals. The value of the design is expressed in terms of a social welfare function which is derived from Arrow’s formulation of social choice. Making certain simplifying assumptions the social welfare function can be expressed in terms of individuals’ ideal designs. A method for estimating the social welfare function from quite limited empirical evidence is developed. The method is applied to an educational case study. There was considerable variation in individuals’ ideal designs. The components of the social welfare were estimated: the welfare ideal, the population sensitivity, the population variation, the deviation from the ideal and the welfare ceiling. Methodological problems are discussed.     

Estimating the conditional mode of a stationary stochastic process from noisy observations

Let {(X _i, Y _i,)}, i≥1, be a strictly stationary process from noisy observations. We examine the effect of the noise in the response Y and the covariates X on the nonparametric estimation of the conditional mode function. To estimate this function we are using deconvoluting kernel estimators. The asymptotic behavior of these estimators depends on the smoothness of the noise distribution, which is classified as either ordinary smooth or super smooth. Uniform convergence with almost sure convergence rates is established for strongly mixing stochastic processes, when the noise distribution is ordinary smooth. Received: April 1998     

Bayesian U-type design for nonparametric response surface prediction

This paper deals with Bayesian design over U-type designs of n runs and s factors with q levels for nonparametric response surface prediction. The criterion is developed in terms of the asymptotic approach of Mitchell et al. (Ann Statist 22: 634–651, 1994) for a specific covariance kernel. An optimal design is given in approximate design theory over the all level combinations. A connection with orthogonality and aberration is established. A lower bound for the criterion is provided, and numerical results show that this lower bound is tight.     

On unordering Horvitz and Thompson'sT 1 class of linear estimators

Summary When elements of a finite population are sampled with varying probability selection at each draw,Horvitz andThompson [1952] have formulated certain classes of linear estimators to bear on the problem of providing a smaple appraisal of the population total.Horvitz andThompson's T ₁ class is an ordered one, which was examined by the present author [1967 b]. For some sampling procedures a best estimator exists for theT ₁ class. Subsequently the present author [1967 c] appliedMurthy's technique [Murthy 1967] of unordering an ordered estimator and derived a more efficient estimator. The present paper is concerned with applyingMurthy's technique to theT ₁ class itself, and examining the unorderedT ₁ class. Curiously enough, it is noted that the condition of unbiasedness is sufficient to completely specify the unorderedT ₁ class for the sampling procedure considered here.Research sponsored by Marathwada University, Aurangabad, India; under Grant No. Research-12-68-69/3314-16.     

On a bayesian criterion for choosing predictive sub-models in linear regression

Summary We treat the model selection problem in regression as a decision problem in which the decisions are the alternative predictive distributions based on the different sub-models and the parameter space is the set of possible future values of the regressand. The loss function balances out the conflicting needs for a predictive distribution with mean close to the true value ofy but without too great a variation. The treatment is Bayesian and the criterion derived is a Bayesian generalization of Mallows (1973)C _p , the Bivar criterion (Young 1982) and AIC (Akaike 1974). An application using a graphical sensitivity analysis is presented.     

A general framework for frontier estimation with panel data

The main objective of the paper is to present a general framework for estimating production frontier models with panel data. A sample of firms i = 1, ..., N is observed on several time periods t = 1, ... T. In this framework, nonparametric stochastic models for the frontier will be analyzed. The usual parametric formulations of the literature are viewed as particular cases and the convergence of the obtained estimators in this general framework are investigated. Special attention is devoted to the role of N and of T on the speeds of convergence of the obtained estimators. First, a very general model is investigated. In this model almost no restriction is imposed on the structure of the model or of the inefficiencies. This model is estimable from a nonparametric point of view but needs large values of T and of N to obtain reliable estimates of the individual production functions and estimates of the frontier function. Then more specific nonparametric firm effect models are presented. In these cases, only NT must be large to estimate the common production function; but again both large N and T are needed for estimating individual efficiencies and for estimating the frontier. The methods are illustrated through a numerical example with real data.     

SELECTION BIAS CORRECTIONS BASED ON THE MULTINOMIAL LOGIT MODEL: MONTE CARLO COMPARISONS

Abstract.  This survey presents the set of methods available in the literature on selection bias correction, when selection is specified as a multinomial logit model. It contrasts the underlying assumptions made by the different methods and shows results from a set of Monte Carlo experiments. We find that, in many cases, the approach initiated by Dubin and MacFadden (1984) as well as the semi-parametric alternative recently proposed by Dahl (2002) are to be preferred to the most commonly used Lee (1983) method. We also find that a restriction imposed in the original Dubin and MacFadden paper can be waived to achieve more robust estimators. Monte Carlo experiments also show that selection bias correction based on the multinomial logit model can provide fairly good correction for the outcome equation, even when the IIA hypothesis is violated.