Who is responsible for rehabilitating the poor? The case for church-based financial services for the poor

This article is a qualitative study, the first part of an ongoing empirical study on the role of churches in providing financial access to the poor. It begins with the question of whether Christian Churches should be involved in providing financial services for the poor. Drawing on the teachings of the Bible, Catholic Social Teachings (CSTs), it concludes that providing such a service is consistent with Christian principles. It then uses the theory of people's psychological sense of a community, the Bible, CST and the extant literature to develop a number of propositions that could form a framework for church-based micro-finance institutions (MFIs).     

Provisioning over the business cycle: Some insights from the microfinance industry

This paper investigates the drivers of provisioning in MFIs and their provisioning behaviour over the business cycle. Based on an international sample of MFIs extracted from the MIX database over the 2001–2014 period, we uncover a negative relationship between MFIs' provisioning and the business cycle. Our finding corroborates the fact that MFIs do not build their loan loss provisions (LLP) during economic booms when profit and earnings are high. Since they provision more during downturns, they are more likely to suffer from unexpected losses and experience failure. This is in sharp contrast with the current Basel III countercyclical buffer requirement suggesting that financial institutions, especially banks, should build sufficient buffer in booms so that they can avoid costly capital adjustment when the economy contracts. Deeper analyses suggest however that this behaviour mainly concerns profit-oriented and deposit-taking/regulated MFIs, with business model and target close to conventional banking. This suggests that bank-like and regulated MFIs' loan loss provisions follow similar behavioral patterns to those of the conventional banking sector during the boom-and-bust cycles.     

Efficiency of Microfinance Institutions: A Data Envelopment Analysis

This study examines the cost efficiency of 39 microfinance institutions across Africa, Asia and the Latin America using non-parametric data envelopment analysis. Our findings show non-governmental microfinance institutions particularly; under production approach, are the most efficient and this result is consistent with their fulfillment of dual objectives: alleviating poverty and simultaneously achieving financial sustainability. However, bank-microfinance institutions also outperform in the measure of efficiency under intermediation approach. This result reflects that banks are the financial intermediaries and have access to local capital market. It may be possible that bank-microfinance institutions may outperform the non-governmental microfinance institutions in the long run.     

A theory and contractual framework of Islamic micro-financial institutions’ operations

Microfinance is seen as a ‘new paradigm’ for bringing about development and eradicating poverty. Many studies prove that the provision of small amounts of credit to the poor is crucial in this new paradigm. However, these studies mainly focus on the conventional microfinance institutions (MFIs) which have already existed for a couple of decades. Their role in helping the poor to achieve higher income and higher standards of living has been well recognized. Currently, there are quite a few MFIs that are operating based on Islamic principles. Although a few studies have been conducted on this subject, the literature lacks a comprehensive theoretical framework to describe the Islamic microfinance institutions (IMFIs). This article explores the contractual framework in modelling the IMFIs, on the one hand, and discusses the role of IMFIs via various modes of financing in providing capital to micro-enterprises, on the other.     

东南亚国家农村扶贫信贷制度的比较与启示

贫困是阻碍发展和威胁社会稳定的重要因素,金融扶贫是帮助贫困农户脱贫致富的重要途径,借助金融扶贫是广大发展中国家普遍采用的一种反贫困方法。本文考察了孟加拉、印度尼西亚、印度、马来西亚等东南亚国家的农村扶贫信贷制度状况,对各国农村扶贫信贷制度的共性和差异进行了比较分析,并对各国农村扶贫信贷制度建设经验进行了总结,在此基础上,针对我国农村扶贫信贷制度给出了有关创新的政策启示。     

Financial Institutions and Non‐Governmental Organizations: An Advocacy Partnership for Sustainable Capital Markets?

In this article, the Chief Responsibility Officer for Aviva Investors examines the potential for financial institutions (FIs) to work in partnership with non‐governmental organizations (NGOs) in advocating changes to public policy that promote sustainable capital markets. Many NGOs have argued that the current form of global economic growth is unsustainable—and they routinely engage in public policy advocacy. However, such advocacy has generally proved ineffective, in large part because most NGOs have a very limited understanding of how capital markets function. Investors, for their part, are increasingly recognizing that key aspects of the global economy are on an unsustainable footing. And some are concerned about the negative implications for the long‐term value of their assets. But with a few notable exceptions, they have not made systematic efforts to work with governments to correct the market failures. NGO‐FI advocacy partnerships could identify specific cases of systemic or sectoral market failures, and recommend long‐term changes to the sectoral operating environment that would affect the cash flows and values of companies operating within that sector in ways designed to “internalize” the effects of negative social and environmental externalities. To foster the development of such partnerships, there is a need for academia to develop learning forums that stimulate the exchange of ideas between the executives within NGOs and FIs in an environment of mutual trust and respect.     

Microfinance institutions,financial intermediation and the role of deposits

Microfinance institutions (MFIs), widely regarded as bankers to the poor, have extended their financial functions beyond lending to managing deposits. We empirically examine the influence of MFI deposit-taking on MFI financial performance. Using data of 1,301 MFIs worldwide, we find that an MFI's deposit level is an important determinant of its financial viability. However, the relationship is influenced by MFIs’ institutional type (for-profit or nonprofit) and the legal environment (common law or civil law). The results suggest that the positive financial impact of deposits has not been fully realised, reflecting the need to further improve cost management and revenue generation.     

小额信贷机构的全要素生产率——基于30家小额信贷机构的实证分析

本研究运用30家小额信贷机构2005～2009年的投入产出数据和基于数据包络分析(DEA)的Malmquist生产率指数法,对小额信贷机构的全要素生产率进行测算和分解.实证结果表明:在时间序列上,30家小额信贷机构整体全要素生产力呈下降趋势.引起生产力下降的原因是规模效率低和技术进步缓慢,规模和技术进步成为小额信贷机构...     

Loan recommender system for microfinance loans: Increasing efficiency to assist growth

A majority of the world's population does not have access to basic financial services. Therefore, financial inclusion is gaining attention from different governments, Non-governmental Organizations and private institutions. Microfinance Institutions (MFIs) have made a significant impact in the field of financial inclusion. But this impact is just the tip of the iceberg and these institutions need to grow exponentially and have efficient processes to have a more meaningful impact. In this article we discuss the design and implementation of a decision support system to help the MFIs achieve that target. We discuss an adaptive loan recommender system that assists the MFIs in making a more informed decision and help them grow with minimum resources. The article also discusses the implementation of this system in one MFI in India and the observed impact and limitations of the system.     

金融减贫效应的门槛特征分析及实证检验

由于受金融市场进入成本以及穷人初始财富不足的限制,金融发展对贫困减缓的影响往往会表现出门槛特征。本文利用1997—2012年我国30个省市的面板数据,以经济发展水平作为门槛变量,对金融发展与贫困减缓之间的关系进行了实证检验。结果表明：在不同的经济发展水平下,金融发展减缓贫困的作用存在显著的差异。只有当经济发展水平越过相应的门槛、穷人达到一定的资本积累后,金融发展才对贫困减缓具有显著的正向效应。这也进一步说明,只有实现金融与经济的协调发展才能更好地发挥金融发展的减贫效应。     

贫困地区金融供求分析与建立普惠金融服务体系的建议

引入普惠金融服务体系,建立健全适应"三农"特点的多层次、广覆盖、可持续的农村金融体系正成为社会各界有识之士的共识.本文从贫困地区的金融需求和金融服务状况入手,阐述了建立普惠金融服务体系对满足贫困地区特殊的金融需求、改善贫困地区金融供给难以适应金融需求的现状、完善农村金融体系的重大意义.提出了构建普惠金融服务体系的具体思路.     

Performance and governance in microfinance institutions

We examine the relationship between firm performance and corporate governance in microfinance institutions (MFI) using a self-constructed global dataset on MFIs collected from third-party rating agencies. Using random effects panel data estimations, we study the effects of board and CEO characteristics, firm ownership type, customer-firm relationship, and competition and regulation on an MFI’s financial performance and outreach to poor clients. We find that financial performance improves with local rather than international directors, an internal board auditor, and a female CEO. The number of credit clients increase with CEO/chairman duality. Outreach is lower in the case of lending to individuals than in the case of group lending. We find no difference between non-profit organisations and shareholder firms in financial performance and outreach, and we find that bank regulation has no effect. The results underline the need for an industry specific approach to MFI governance.     

Cocreating business's new social compact

Moving beyond decades of mutual distrust and animosity, corporations and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) are learning to cooperate with each other. Realizing that their interests are converging, the two sides are working together to create innovative business models that are helping to grow new markets and accelerate the eradication of poverty. The path to convergence has proceeded in three stages. In the initial be-responsible stage, companies and NGOs, realizing that they had to coexist, started to look for ways to influence each other through joint social responsibility projects. This experience paved the way for the get-into-business stage, in which NGOs and companies sought to serve the poor by setting up successful businesses. In the process, NGOs learned business discipline from the private sector, while corporations gained an appreciation for the local knowledge, low-cost business models, and community-based marketing techniques that the NGOs have mastered. Increased success on both sides has laid the foundation for the cocreate-business stage, in which companies and NGOs become key parts of each other's capacity to deliver value. When BP sought to market a duel-fuel portable stove in India, it set up one such cocreation system with three Indian NGOs. The system allowed BP to bring the innovative stove to a geographically dispersed market through myriad local distributors without incurring distribution costs so high that the product would become unaffordable. The company sold its stoves profitably, the NGOs gained access to a lucrative revenue stream that could fund other projects, and consumers got more than the ability to sit down to a hot meal-they got the opportunity to earn incomes as the local distributors and thus to gain economic and social influence.     

Morgan Stanley's Approach to Assessing Credit Risks in the Microfinance Industry

Growing investor interest in microfinance combined with strong demand from microfinance institutions (MFIs) for capital have caused the financial industry and rating agencies to seek more reliable and precise methods for assessing the risks of MFIs. Drawing on the work of various industry leaders as well as its own experience, Morgan Stanley's Microfinance Institutions Group has created a comprehensive internal credit analysis and rating methodology—one that, by producing global (foreign and local currency) scale ratings, enables its analysts to assess and compare risks both within the growing microfinance sector and relative to other sectors.     

International diversification and Microfinance

International commercial banks, institutional investors, and private investors have become increasingly interested in financing microfinance institutions (MFIs). This paper investigates whether adding microfinance funds to a portfolio of risky international assets yields diversification gains. By using mean-variance spanning tests with short-sale constraints, we find that investing in microfinance may be attractive for investors seeking a better risk-return profile. Specifically, the analysis suggests that investing in MFIs from Latin America, or microfinance and rural banks yields more efficient portfolios. In contrast, adding MFIs from Africa or microfinance NGOs to a portfolio of international assets is not beneficial for a mean-variance investor.     

Finance is good for the poor but it depends where you live

I examine whether or not the incomes of the poor systematically grow with average incomes, and whether financial development enhances the incomes of the poorest quintile. Following the methodology of Dollar and Kraay (2002), I find, once extending Dollar and Kraay’s data, their findings are robust to the Lucas critique and economic growth is important for poverty reduction universally. However, in comparison to other authors’ work I show financial development aids the incomes of the poor in certain regions, whilst it may be detrimental in others. This proposes evidence against a “one size fits all” model adding a further contribution to the literature on financial development and poverty.     

Scale economies and input price elasticities in microfinance institutions

We evaluate the efficiency of microfinance institutions (MFIs) using a structural approach which also captures these institutions’ outreach and sustainability objectives. We estimate economies of scale and input price elasticities for lending-only and deposit-mobilizing MFIs using a large sample of high-quality panel data. The results confirm conjectures that improvements in efficiency can come from the growth or consolidations of MFIs, as we find substantial increasing returns to scale for all but profitability-focused deposit-mobilizing MFIs. Our results support the existence of a trade-off between outreach and sustainability. All inputs are inelastic substitutes, but we find differences in own-price elasticities in lending-only and deposit-mobilizing MFIs.     

The determinants of MFIs’ social and financial performances in sub-Saharan Africa: has mission drift occurred?

This paper studies the determinants of microfinance institutions’ (MFIs) financial performance (FP: self-sustainability and profitability) and social performance (SP: depth of outreach), and examine the FP/SP tradeoffs they face. Based on a sample of 120 MFIs over the period 2000–2009, we use the random effects method to isolate the effect of fixed-time factors such as loan lending technique, legal status and location (sub-region) on MFIs’ behavior. We find that financial expenses, wages and portfolio quality, mainly influence MFIs’ financial performance whereas social performance is mostly influenced by lending methodology and institutional form, and to a lesser extent by location. The analysis of FP–SP shows that mission drift is a concern primarily for banks, mutual/cooperatives and individual lenders. The results question the trend toward microfinance commercialization since it weakens outreach without improving significantly self-sustainability and profitability.     

民族地区微型金融机构社会扶贫功能的统计学分析——基于对湖北省恩施土家苗族自治州的调研数据

摘要：本文对恩施州从农信社获得过贷款的农户进行了实地调研,并结合从当地农信社获得的数据,利用SPSS17．0分析软件,从覆盖力的视角对恩施州农信社的社会扶贫功能进行了全方位的统计描述。研究发现：以农信社为首的微型金融机构的社会扶贫功能在一定程度上得到实现,但微型金融机构已出现偏离其“社会扶贫”功能的趋势,而且,金融服务落后和金融产品单一是制约微型金融机构社会扶贫功能的主要因素。