A look at the public policy conflict regarding the discovery of accountants' tax accrual workpapers

This article focuses on the conflict in public policy between the need to provide the investing public with accurate information with regard to corporate financial statements and the need to provide the IRS with the necessary tools in order to assure corporate compliance with the tax laws of the country. The conflict arises because of the contention of the IRS that it is entitled to have access to an independent auditor's tax accrual workpapers on the one hand, and the contention by CPAs that such access will prevent adequate disclosure to the independent auditor. The article examines the policy questions on both sides of the issue and concludes that regardless of any decision by the Supreme Court in a pendingcase, Congress should pass legislation to resolve the conflict and clearly identify the scope of any previlage accorded with regard to tax accrual workpapers.     

Failure prediction: Sensitivity of classification accuracy to alternative statistical methods and variable sets

The purpose of this study was to assess the sensitivity of the prediction of business failure to the use of different variable sets and different statistical methods. This objective was accomplished by comparing the performance of failure prediction models using four alternative variable sets on firms which failed from 1966–1975. The four sets of variables were those used by Altman (1968), Deakin (1972), Blum (1974), and Ohlson (1980). A linear discriminant model, a quadratic discriminant model, and a logit model were developed for each of the four variable sets. For a given variable sets, the linear and logit models had comparable misclassification rates and performed at least as well as the quadratic models. Using linear discriminant analysis or logit analysis, all four variable sets performed comparably.     

Systematic risk and the theory of the firm: A reexamination

A recent microeconomic model of the determinants of equity betas (Subrahmanyam and Thomadakis 1980) is generalized by including risky human capital in the market portfolio and allowing a general covariance structure between the model's sources of uncertainty. This provides an explanation of the ambiguous effect of operating leverage on beta by viewing human capital and equity contributors as risk sharers in the firm's output risk. This explanation may help to clarify the apparent conflict with the previous literature. The relationship between systematic risk and monopoly power is rederived and shown to depend upon a plausible condition on the correlation between wage rate and price uncertainty. Finally, the public policy implications of this analysis are presented.     

The investment tax credit in capital replacement: A simulation

Congressional intent in passing various versions of the investment tax credit has been to stimulate increased investment in capital goods. This paper examines the impact of ITC on the replacement component of investment from the standpoint of the individual firm. The simulations run assume that the firm incorporates correctly all tax effects, to arrive at the optimal replacement decision. The results imply that from the micro standpoint, the law does not necessarily generate the intended behavior. As implications for policy, further research in this area should focus on individual firm action rather than on macro models.     

Tax reform: Analyzing a comprehensive income tax

This paper includes an analysis of the general costs and benefits associated with the introduction of a comprehensive income tax. The introduction of a comprehensive income tax may result in such benefits as simplicity, horizontal equity, and neutrality that may, in turn, be offset by the costs in vertical equity, implementation losses, and efficiency losses. The solution to the question of the desirability of the comprehensive income tax may turn upon the nature of these costs and benefits as well as the philosophy of tax reform that is adopted.     

The importance of state accounting practices for creditor decisions

This paper examines the association between state government accounting practices and creditor decisions. Creditor decisions were surrogated by yield premiums and variances of the premiums on general obligation debt securities. Accounting practices were summarized from the Council of State Governments Survey. In addition to these practices, accounting ratios and bond ratings were included as independent variables in regression models. The results demonstrated that accounting practices were not directly associated with the bond risk and return measures but may have been indirectly related as a result of their effect on bond ratings.     

The effects of tax provisions on long-run investment prospects

This paper examines the implications of the tax system on the long-run investment prospects for several classes of securities, including short-term debt, long-term debt, and equity. Combining apparently reasonable assumptions with tax provisions that are similar to those of the prevailing federal system, we indicate that equity may be the only investment medium that promises a positive real, after-tax return to a taxable investor.By modifying selected tax provisions that relate to investment activities, such that the recognition of unrealized appreciation is deferred and the investment itself leads to an immediate deduction, substantially different long-run implications are produced. In particular, under reasonable assumptions all classes of investments (with the possible exception of Treasury bills) appear to promise a positive real, after-tax return     

Class-action privileges and contingent legal fees: Investor and lawyer incentives to litigate and the effect on audit quality

The Cohen Commission recognized the importance of litigation incentives and recommended that research based upon an economic approach be conducted into the effects that litigation incentives can have on the auditing profession. By extending Simon (1981), an economic analysis of an auditing environment is presented wherein audit firms issue reports, representative investors make decisions based upon audit reports, and lawyers (as well as representative investors) play an active role in determining whether or not to initiate litigation against audit firms. The influence that alternative litigation privileges (i.e., class-action privileges with contingent legal fees and no class-action privileges with fixed legal fees) have on representative investor and lawyer incentives to litigate and on the equilibrium characteristics of this audit market are analyzed.     

Pension ratios as “correlates” of municipal pension underfunding

Unlike the corporate sector, detailed estimates of unfunded pension liabilities for most local governments are not available. Thus, prior research on the association between unfunded pension liabilities and municipal creditor decisions (Copeland and Ingram 1983; Marks and Raman 1985) has implicitly assumed that certain pension ratios are good surrogates for municipal pension underfunding. In this paper, we rely on a theoretical model by Ehrenberg (1980) to test empirically the appropriateness of pension ratios as “correlates” of municipal pension underfunding. These ratios were found to be correlated with pension underfunding, although they accounted for only about 30 percent of the variance in the underfunding variable.     

Accounting information and municipal bond net interest cost: An empirical evaluation

The objective of this study was to test the association between the surplus/deficit of selected Minnesota municipalities and the net interest cost of the general obligation bonds issued by these municipalities. This objective was accomplished by employing a pooled time-series design.A two-way analysis of variance was used to determine if there was a significant difference in the effect of net interest cost between positive and negative forecast errors. The ANOVA results of both tests indicate that the surplus/deficit is not correlated with increases/ decreases in the net interest cost of the bonds issued by a municipality. The results were unaffected by the exclusion of bond ratings as an independent variable.