Cost effectiveness of transcatheter aortic valve replacement compared to medical management in inoperable patients with severe aortic stenosis: Canadian analysis based on the PARTNER Trial Cohort B findings

Abstract

Objective:

The only effective treatment for severe aortic stenosis (AS) is valve replacement. However, many patients with co-existing conditions are ineligible for surgical valve replacement, historically leaving medical management (MM) as the only option which has a poor prognosis. Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement (TAVR) is a less invasive replacement method. The objective was to estimate cost-effectiveness of TAVR via transfemoral access vs MM in surgically inoperable patients with severe AS from the Canadian public healthcare system perspective.

Methods:

A cost-effectiveness analysis of TAVR vs MM was conducted using a deterministic decision analytic model over a 3-year time horizon. The PARTNER randomized controlled trial results were used to estimate survival, utilities, and some resource utilization. Costs included the valve replacement procedure, complications, hospitalization, outpatient visits/tests, and home/nursing care. Resources were valued (2009 Canadian dollars) using costs from the Ontario Case Costing Initiative (OCCI), Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care and Ontario Drug Benefits Formulary, or were estimated using relative costs from a French economic evaluation or clinical experts. Costs and outcomes were discounted 5% annually. The effect of uncertainty in model parameters was explored in deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analysis.

Results:

The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was $32,170 per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained for TAVR vs MM. When the time horizon was shortened to 24 and 12 months, the ICER increased to $52,848 and $157,429, respectively. All other sensitivity analysis returned an ICER of less than $50,000/QALY gained.

Limitations:

A limitation was lack of availability of Canadian-specific resource and cost data for all resources, leaving one to rely on clinical experts and data from France to inform certain parameters.

Conclusions:

Based on the results of this analysis, it can be concluded that TAVR is cost-effective compared to MM for the treatment of severe AS in surgically inoperable patients.     

洞庭湖的演化与生态

洞庭湖会消亡，三峡水库运行只能延长其寿命，是目前的主导认识。根据构造沉降和泥沙淤积的相对关系，近100年来洞庭湖的演化经历了下荆江裁弯前后的萎缩和基本保持不变两个阶段；三峡水库蓄水135m高程标志着进入湖的扩大阶段；洞庭湖湿地生态系统受洞庭湖演化、“泥沙淤积搬家”和三峡水库年内下泄量变化等三个主要因素的影响，在其综合作用下，湿地生态系统由顺向演替转化为逆向演替。如此，三峡水库运行将使洞庭湖的生态问题出现一系列新的变化，将成为湖区可持续发展等同于防洪的重大问题。     

事业单位养老保险改革替代率分析

我国事业单位养老保险改革迫在眉睫。本文通过比较事业单位养老保险试点前后的不同方案,计算两种制度下的养老金替代率,得出试点方案中的养老金替代率与改革前、企业职工养老保险养老金替代率均存在较大差距。从而说明各试点省市事业单位养老保险改革进程缓慢主要在于待遇水平大幅度降低。由此提出早日建立职业年金制度的建议。     

资源减量化、信息替代与经济流程的转变

资源对经济长期增长的约束问题是当前理论界的焦点，现有的循环经济研究没有走出传统经济理论的困境。作为循环经济的核心，资源减量化的精义在于减少生产环节之前和生产过程中对资源的无谓消耗，避免大规模生产条件下盲目竞争导致的产品过剩问题，实现微观领域的产销平衡和宏观领域的总供需平衡。为此，必须对社会经济流程进行再造，即通过信患资源替代物质资源，使交换在生产之前发生，即虚拟交换前置。     

国有企业改制中职工身份置换模式的再认识

通过建立三权互动的改制模式深化国有企业改革,对促进经济协调发展和维护社会稳定具有十分重要的战略意义。而建立这种模式的关键就是对改制过程中产生的“弱势群体”进行有效的救助。当前以“平均主义”为主要特征的身份置换模式虽然取得了促进产业结构调整等一系列积极效果,但由于缺乏科学和系统的规划,在制度设计和运行中并未遵循“弱者救助”的逻辑,出现了以不科学、不公正和低效率为主要内容的制度缺陷,迫切需要从制度上予以规范和改进。     

财产保险的保险价值界定探析——解读新《保险法》第55条

保险价值在财产保险中占有核心地位,是确定赔付比例和赔偿限额的标准。在实务和媒体报道中,财产保险索赔争议案例多与对保险价值的不同理解有关。本文将通过案例分析保险法和保险条款对保险价值界定中存在的问题,并对保险价值相关立法和司法解释的进一步完善提出合理建议。     

A technology replacement model with variable market potential — An empirical study of CRT and LCD TV

The rapidly changing economic environment and increasingly fierce competition indicate that companies must innovate in both their products and marketing strategies if they are to continue to flourish. Specifically, the ability to accurately predict the demand for products is crucial when firms decide to allocate their resources, especially in the fast moving high technology industries, where there is very high investment in R&D and production facilities. This study establishes a forecast model for technology replacement based on the diffusion model with population growth used for the variable market potential. The proposed model is then applied to investigate the CRT and LCD TV market.The results suggest that the new model is more accurate than the constant market potential model in fitting and forecasting performance. Consumers who purchase a TV for the first time are likely more attracted to LCD TV rather than CRT TV. As for those individuals who already own a CRT TV, the attraction is not strong enough to encourage them to replace their current CRT TV with a new LCD TV. Moreover, it is noted that the falling price of LCD TV is an essential factor in encouraging purchases.     

债务置换改善了地方政府债务可持续性吗？

2015年后实施的债务置换对地方政府债务可持续性的影响值得关注。为此,将债务置换作为准自然实验,以2008—2020年285个城市为样本,检验债务置换对债务可持续性的影响。结果发现：债务置换对隐性债务和经济增长产生了双重不利影响。其一,债务置换降低债务利息负担,拉长债务期限,虽然缓解了流动性风险,但债务置换助长地方政府道德风险,强化金融机构救助预期,导致隐性债务继续增加,总体上不利于债务可持续性。其二,债务置换产生明显挤出效应,也降低了地方政府债务支出效率,损害了经济增长,同样不利于债务可持续性。鉴于此,应重点防范债务置换过程中产生的负面作用,以提高地方政府债务治理的有效性。     

矿产品消费及其资源保障

矿产品是人类取得物质和能量的主要来源。能 (量资 )源比物质资源更重要。能源矿产品的用途既可以是能源 ,也可能是物质资源 (有机化工原料 )。物质资源消费趋势是单耗和总耗都趋于降低。能源的生产消费应追求单耗降低而总耗稳定 ;生活消费在中国当前则应是单耗和总耗都合理稳步上升。调剂地区之间能源余缺应以直接输能 (电 )为主 ,运输能源物质为辅 ,因此应提高电在能源终端消费中的比重。不同能源替代余地大 ,短缺表现为总量短缺 ,国家宏观调控能发挥重要作用 ;不同物质资源替代余地小 ,短缺表现为结构性短缺 ,应更多地发挥市场机制的作用     

巴布亚新几内亚Mendi-Kandep公路软基处置设计与实现

以巴布亚新几内亚Mendi-Kandep公路为背景,介绍了在热带多雨地区资源匮乏的情况下公路软基处置的换填垫层法和土工织物加固法结合使用的效果,说明这种方法的有效性和经济性,同时通过现场试验确定了土工织物的布设及受力特点,并对垫层尺寸的计算方法进行了说明。