Bank liquidity risk: From John Law (1705) to Walter Bagehot (1873)

Abstract

By granting credit and issuing money, banks take a liquidity risk - that is, the risk of being unable to reimburse its notes in coins. Five different explanations of a bank liquidity crisis have been provided by different authors, since John Law and up to Walter Bagehot. First, according to Law (1703) and Steuart (1767] 1998]), the distinction between money of account (the pound sterling) and money of payment (the guinea) may induce a bank run. Second, according to Cantillon (1730), Hume (1752 Goschen, G. J., 1861. The Theory of the Foreign Exchanges. London; Effingham Wilson, Royal, 1861. French edition, Théorie des changes étrangers, Librairie Guillaumin et C^ie Paris, 1892. 1861. Google Scholar]] 1972), Ricardo (1810-1823) and the Currency School (1837-1858), the bank reserve becomes insufficient as a consequence of a diminishing value of money allied with over issues. Third, according to Thornton (1802 Skaggs, N. T., 2010b. "For the love of truth: Henry Thornton's stance in the bullion committee debates. 2010 meeting of the History of Economics Society, Syracuse". 2010b. Google Scholar]] 1939, 1991 Skaggs, N. T., 2010b. "For the love of truth: Henry Thornton's stance in the bullion committee debates. 2010 meeting of the History of Economics Society, Syracuse". 2010b. Google Scholar]) and the Banking School (1840-1857), it can occur as a consequence of a falling exchange rate that is not linked with over issues. Fourth, according to Smith (1776) and the Banking School, discounting of fictitious bills, by decreasing the shareholders' funds, leads to bank illiquidity. Lastly, according to Thornton (1802 Skaggs, N. T., 2010b. "For the love of truth: Henry Thornton's stance in the bullion committee debates. 2010 meeting of the History of Economics Society, Syracuse". 2010b. Google Scholar]] 1939, 1991 Skaggs, N. T., 2010b. "For the love of truth: Henry Thornton's stance in the bullion committee debates. 2010 meeting of the History of Economics Society, Syracuse". 2010b. Google Scholar]) and Bagehot (1873), the liquidity crisis is a consequence of bank panics: a "flight" to money for Thornton, a "flight" to credit for Bagehot. The analysis of these five different explanations sheds new light on classical monetary controversies.