For or Against Corporate Identity? Personification and the Problem
of Moral Agency |
| |
Authors: | Ian Ashman Diana Winstanley |
| |
Institution: | (1) Department of Strategy and Innovation, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, PR1 2HE, U.K.;(2) Kingston Business School, Kingston University, Kingston, Surrey, KT2 7LB, U.K. |
| |
Abstract: | This article explores the concept of corporate identity from a moral perspective. In it we argue that the reification and
personification involved in attributing an identity to an organization has moral repercussions. Through a discussion of ‘intentionality’
we suggest that it is philosophically problematic to treat an abstraction of the corporation as possessing identity or acting
as a conscious moral agent. The article moves to consider practical and ethical issues in the areas of organizational commitment,
of health and safety, and corporate social responsibility, and finds that the notion of identity can be abused, although it
will no doubt continue to be used as it does have some practical utility. In conclusion, we argue that despite being meaningless
from a philosophical stance, the concept of corporate identity need not be discarded, however, it is far from benign and intense
moral scrutiny is necessary wherever it is applied.
Ian Ashman PhD is a senior lecturer in the HRM division of the Lancashire business School, University of Central Lancashire.
He has recently authored a number of papers on business ethics, leadership and research methods, all of which draw upon his
interest in philosophies of existential phenomenology. He is an executive member of European Business Ethics Network U.K.
Professor Diana Winstanley PhD, FCIPD was Director of Postgraduate Programmes at Kingston Business School, Kingston University.
She wrote over 50 articles and five books, including her latest, ‚Personal Effectiveness: A Guide to Action’ (2005, CIPD)
and Ethical Issues in Contemporary Human Resource Development (2000, Macmillan). She was a trained humanistic counsellor and
an executive member of European Business Ethics Network U.K. Her research interests were in the areas of workplace learning,
development, diversity and business ethics. Sadly, Diana Winstanley, died last summer. |
| |
Keywords: | corporate identity intentionality moral agency reification social responsibility |
本文献已被 SpringerLink 等数据库收录! |
|