新《公司法》的反思

2005年修改通过的新《公司法》,是一个符合我国实际较为成熟的法律文本。但反思新《公司法》,还存在一些明显的缺陷:因法定准用制不周延而导致的结构性失衡,应予以调整;对中小企业关注不够,有限责任公司应更凸显自治和简化;一人公司的过度规制易导致逆向选择,且在适用法人格否认制度上存在实际的困难,其各项制度价值的平衡还需要继续探讨;法人格否认制度的移植过于超前,应更重视建立滥用公司法人格的积极防御机制等。

Reflections on the New Corporation Act

The new Corporation Act that was modified and passed in 2005 is a relatively mature law matching our nation's actual situation.But we can still find some obvious defects through reflections on the new Corporation Act: Unbalance of structure due to the incomplete legal approval institution should be adjusted; The law doesn't pay adequate attention to the medium and small scale business enterprises,autonomy and simplification should be highlighted in the limited corporation;Excessive ruling system of one-person corporation leads to the contrary choice easily.Meanwhile,actual difficulties can not be ignored in the application of corporation personality denial institution,and the balance of value between various institutions needs to be probed continuously.Transplantation of corporation personality denial institution seems to be surpassing vanguard,and a new positive defensive mechanism against abusing the corporation personality should be established.