股指期货交易量与股指现货波动关系研究——来自香港恒生指数的实证

文章以香港恒生股票指数及其期货为样本,研究了股指波动性与指数期货交易量之间的关系。研究结果表明,它们之间存在单向因果关系,股指现货市场的日间价格波动并没有明显增加股指期货的交易,但股指期货的交易量却对指数现货的波动性产生延迟影响,这从一定程度上反映了香港市场股指期货主要被投资者用于套利而不是风险对冲的工具。     

基于波动效应与价格发现的期指仿真交易研究

沪深300股指期货仿真交易的推出,对我国现货市场的影响如何以及这种影响是否有利于现货效率的改进。首次采用修正的GARCH模型和向量误差修正模型(VEC)将股指期货推出后现货市场波动性的变化和股指期货与现货市场的价格发现功能结合起来进行对比研究。结果表明,期指仿真交易的推出对于现货市场效率的改进确实存在正面的影响。其引入在短期内加大了现货市场的波动,但这一波动正是市场信息流动加速的反映,因而提高了市场信息的传递效率。同时期货价格领先于现货价格,存在由期货市场到现货市场长期的单向因果关系,说明期货价格具有引导现货价格向均衡方向调整的功能,从而在经验上支持了股指期货市场的开放政策。     

Availability and settlement of individual stock futures and options expiration-day effects: evidence from high-frequency data

This study examines whether the expiration-day effects of stock options traded in Australian Stock Exchange on return, volatility, trading volume, and temporary price changes of individual stocks vary with the availability and the settlement method of individual stock futures contracts. Using transaction data of the stocks that have both options and futures contacts from 1993 to 1997, we find that options expiration has significant effects on return and volatility of the underlying stocks in absence of individual stock futures. After introduction of a cash-settled stock futures contract, the effects decrease notably. However, the switch of a futures contract from cash settlement to physical delivery promotes the expiration effects on return and volatility and boosts temporary price changes on expiration days. Finally, options expiration has little effect on trading volume. Trading activity tends to behave normally regardless whether stock futures contracts are available or not.     

沪深300股指期货在现货交易和非交易时段交易特征的比较研究

我国沪深300股指期货交易2010年4月16日正式推出,但沪深300股指期货市场与沪深300现货市场的交易时间存在显著的差异,即相对于股票现货市场,沪深300股指期货市场提前15分钟开盘,延迟15分钟收盘。运用日内分笔数据和分钟数据,对沪深300股指期货不同交易时段的交易特征进行比较。研究表明,不同交易时段知情交易者市场参与度存在明显差异,提前交易时段知情交易的概率最高,现货交易时段次之,延迟交易时段最低;沪深300股指期货在开盘时段的交易提供了较大的价格发现,特别是开盘的第一笔交易包含有大量的私有信息,价格贡献最大;提前交易时段私有信息的价格发现贡献度最高;尽管提前交易时段的交易提供了较大的价格发现,但定价效率较低。     

离岸与在岸股指期货市场的价格联动关系研究——基于国内股指期货市场受限的实证分析

金融资产的价格发现权是各国经济主权的重要组成部分，关系到市场秩序和国民财富的安全。从历史经验看，一旦在岸市场出现发展迟滞或过度管制等问题，竞争性离岸市场就会利用契机快速发展。以2015年国内股指期货受限事件为自然实验，分析新加坡交易所A50与国内沪深300股指期货的价格联动关系，研究表明：国内市场受限后，A50股指期货的持仓量呈明显上升趋势，承载的避险需求增大，其夜盘和盘前涨跌能有效预测沪深300指数开盘走势；在同步交易时段，沪深300股指期货在价格发现中的贡献度为64.4%，仍明显高于A50股指期货；境内熔断触发后，A50股指期货的成交量没有显著减少，表明在岸市场暂停无法显著制约离岸市场的价格发现能力。     

股票指数期货：工具与监管

本文从股票指数期货在金融交易中发挥的作用、股票指数期货交易的开设对股票市场波动性的影响、以及我国当前的股票市场交易制度与监管三个层面上对开设股票指数期货交易进行分析研究,并指出:就股票指数期货作为一种金融衍生工具而言,我国应该及早引入股票指数期货,以提高股票市场的运作效率。同时考虑到我国经济正在进行深层次的结构性调整,市场交易制度有其自身的特点,当前更应着重加强资本市场的制度建设,提高监管力度,为早日开设股票指数期货交易创造条件。     

涨跌停板制度对期货市场价格发现过程及波动性的影响--基于上海期货交易所的实证研究

本文通过检验在出现涨跌停板之后一个交易日的期货价格及其波动性的变化情况，研究了涨跌停板制度对上海期货交易所期货价格变动的影响。研究结果显示，对不同的期货品种，涨跌停板制度的影响存在一定的差异，但总体而言，涨跌停板制度并没有起到防范价格过度反应和降低市场波动性的作用。相反，在一定程度上延缓了期货市场价格发现功能的发挥，增大了市场的波动性。     

交易量适合作为股价波动信息的代理变量吗?——来自中国沪深股市的证据

本文利用中国沪深股市日交易数据,采用多元GARCH模型从信息传递的角度进行实证研究,结果表明:股价对交易量具有显著的波动溢出效应,但交易量对股价的波动溢出效应不明显。这种波动的单向溢出说明在应对信息的冲击上股价比交易量能更快地做出反应,其后才通过波动溢出在交易量上得到反映,股价波动对成交量波动具有先导作用。因此,从波动冲击传导和信息传递的角度看,单纯地将交易量视为股价变动信息的代理变量还缺乏稳健的统计证据。     

成交量、持仓量对我国大豆类期货价差波动影响的实证分析

采用GARCH(1,1)模型就成交量、持仓量对大豆类期货价差波动率的影响进行实证分析,结果显示：当期成交量、持仓量对大豆期货价差波动的整体影响是显著的;滞后成交量、持仓量对大豆期货价差波动的整体影响也是显著的;当成交量、持仓量同时进入条件方差方程时,它们对大豆类期货价差波动的影响整体上也是显著的。这一结论揭示了我国大豆期货市场信息传递过程,验证了我国大豆期货市场的信息非有效性,对期货市场投资者以及期货市场监管者具有一定的借鉴意义。     

Program Trading and Stock Index Futures: Blessing or Bane?

'Program trading'and stock index futures and options are often blamed for stock market volatility, and especially so after the Crash. Professor Tyler Cowen, of the University of California at Irvine, claims that these new trading techniques have not added to volatility and that regulation could well increase it.     

不同约束条件下的股指期货价格区间研究

在股指期货持有成本定价模型的基础上,结合中国沪深300股指期货合约的特点,根据无套利原理,给出了考虑交易成本、期货保证金和不同借贷利率等限制条件下的股指期货定价区间和相应的交易策略,为从事沪深300股指期货套期保值、套利和投机交易的相关人员提供借鉴意义。     

Position limit for the CSI 300 stock index futures market

The aim of this study was to find the optimal position limit for the Chinese stock index (CSI) 300 futures market. A low position limit helps to prevent price manipulations in the spot market, and thus keeps the magnitude of instantaneous price changes within the tolerance range of policymakers. However, setting a position limit that is too low may also have negative effects on market quality. We propose an artificial limit order market with heterogeneous interacting agents to examine the impact of different levels of position limits on market quality, measured as liquidity, return volatility, efficiency of information dissemination, and trading welfare. The simulation model is based on realistic trading mechanisms, investor structure, and order submission behavior observed in the CSI 300 futures market.Our results show that on the basis of the liquidity status in September 2010, raising the position limit from 100 to 300 could significantly improve market quality and at the same time keep the maximum absolute price change per 5 s below the 2% tolerance level. However, the improvement becomes only marginal if the position limit is further increased beyond 300. Therefore, we believe that raising the position limit to a moderate level can enhance the functionality of the CSI 300 futures market, which should benefit the development of the Chinese financial system.     

Volatility, Efficiency, and Trading: Further Evidence

Along the lines of Amihud and Mendelson (1987a, 1989,1991), this study investigates the unique trading mechanism of the Korea Stock Exchange (KSE) and its intraday behavior of stock price volatility. The evidence from this study indicates that the introduction of an additional clearing procedure at the afternoon closing makes price discovery process more efficient than before from the viewpoint of stock price volatility. Hence, such trading mechanisms can be applied to emerging stock markets as well as developed stock markets. In addition, based on intraday analysis, stock price volatilities appear to occur mainly during the trading period, not during the lunch break or overnight period. Consequently, the results confirm the previous studies that information arrival and trading activities are the main sources of volatility.     

Testing the stabilization hypothesis in the UK short-term interest rates: Evidence from a GARCH-X model

The objective of this paper is to examine the validity of one of the recurring arguments made against futures markets that they give rise to price instability. The paper concentrates on the impact of futures trading on the spot market volatility of short-term interest rates. The analytical framework employed is based on a new statistical approach aiming to reconcile the traditional models of short-term interest rates and the conditional volatility processes. More specifically, this class of models aims to capture the dynamics of short-term interest rate volatility by allowing volatility to depend on both scale effects and information shocks. Using a GARCH-X and asymmetric GARCH-X model four main conclusions emerge from the present study. First, the empirical results suggest that there is an indisputable change in the nature of volatility with evidence of mean reversion after the onset of futures trading. Second, the information flow into the market has improved as a result of futures trading. Third, a stabilization effect has been detected running from the futures market to the cash market by lowering volatility levels and decreasing the risk in the spot market. Finally, trying to capture the leverage effect the findings suggest that positive shocks have a greater impact on volatility than negative shocks.     

Efficient predictability of stock return volatility: The role of stock market implied volatility

This study examines the predictability of stock market implied volatility on stock volatility in five developed economies (the US, Japan, Germany, France, and the UK) using monthly volatility data for the period 2000 to 2017. We utilize a simple linear autoregressive model to capture predictive relationships between stock market implied volatility and stock volatility. Our in-sample results show there exists very significant Granger causality from stock market implied volatility to stock volatility. The out-of-sample results also indicate that stock market implied volatility is significantly more powerful for stock volatility than the oil price volatility in five developed economies.     

基于Morlet小波时频互相关的股指期货价格发现效率研究

本文采用Morlet小波时频互相关分析方法,从"时域"和"频域"两个维度检验了我国以及国际主要市场股指期货和现货价格序列的动态关联性,研究了股指期货价格发现效率的问题。研究表明,沪深300指数和股指期货在低频长周期范围内,呈现长时间高度相关、协同波动的特征;在高频短周期范围内,两者整体仍然具有协同波动特征,但时常出现短暂紊乱的情况,即期货与现货的交错引导现象。我国股指期货市场的价格发现效率较美国、英国成熟市场仍有较大差距,但强于日本。     

Trading and non-trading period realized market volatility: Does it matter for forecasting the volatility of US stocks?

We study the potential merits of using trading and non-trading period market volatilities to model and forecast the stock volatility over the next one to 22 days. We demonstrate the role of overnight volatility information by estimating heterogeneous autoregressive (HAR) model specifications with and without a trading period market risk factor using ten years of high-frequency data for the 431 constituents of the S&P 500 index. The stocks’ own overnight squared returns perform poorly across stocks and forecast horizons, as well as in the asset allocation exercise. In contrast, we find overwhelming evidence that the market-level volatility, proxied by S&P Mini futures, matters significantly for improving the model fit and volatility forecasting accuracy. The greatest model fit and forecast improvements are found for short-term forecast horizons of up to five trading days, and for the non-trading period market-level volatility. The documented increase in forecast accuracy is found to be associated with the stocks’ sensitivity to the market risk factor. Finally, we show that both the trading and non-trading period market realized volatilities are relevant in an asset allocation context, as they increase the average returns, Sharpe ratios and certainty equivalent returns of a mean–variance investor.     

Open interest,volume, and volatility: evidence from Taiwan futures markets

This paper examines the relationships amongst volatility, total trading volume (TVOL) and total open interest (TOI) for three Taiwan stock index futures markets as well as the role of the latter two variables in the dynamics of GARCH modeling and forecasting. From both ex-post and ex-ante perspectives, we study this issue by using the VAR model and augmented GARCH-type models, respectively. For the GARCH-type models, we employ both symmetric and asymmetric models augmented with lagged logs in TOI and/or TVOL. We find that whether addition of these two variables helps the basic GARCH models predict future volatility depends upon the sample period examined for all three sets of futures. Nonetheless, the best three models for out-of-sample volatility forecasting in the MSE sense are generally the augmented models for all sub-intervals and all three futures contracts.     

The role of oil futures intraday information on predicting US stock market volatility

This study investigates the role of oil futures price information on forecasting the US stock market volatility using the HAR framework. In-sample results indicate that oil futures intraday information is helpful to increase the predictability. Moreover, compared to the benchmark model, the proposed models improve their predictive ability with the help of oil futures realized volatility. In particular, the multivariate HAR model outperforms the univariate model. Accordingly, considering the contemporaneous connection is useful to predict the US stock market volatility. Furthermore, these findings are consistent across a variety of robust checks.     

我国沪深300股指期货价格发现功能的实证分析

我国股指期货的推出对证券市场产生了巨大的影响,改变了股票市场缺乏规避系统性风险工具的现状,给金融市场带来新的生机与活力。本文采用协整检验、误差修正模型、方差分解和脉冲响应函数实证分析了我国股票市场和期货市场的价格发现功能。研究发现股指期货在价格发现上占主导地位,表明我国股指期货的推出,增强了市场效率,使市场信息能够更快捷的传达。